Especially in specialty coffee, there is increasingly talk of transparency and traceability along the coffee chain. However, what do these terms mean? And what advantages or disadvantages do they bring to a company in its communication? And what is their explanatory value?
David Wistorf from the Kaffeemacher looked into these questions in his bachelor's thesis. The work is comprehensive, introducing the subject matter with a thorough literature section and culminating in David's own model for measuring transparency.
Here David summarizes the key points from his work. He also makes his bachelor's thesis freely accessible.
At the Kaffeemacher, David's inputs are having a big impact right now and we are planning to advance our approach to how we want to report on coffees. And that is what David's work should accomplish – it should question and provide new ideas.
David Wistorf: Management Summary
The price for a pound of Arabica coffee on October 17, 2019 was around 0.92 US dollars. This price has been falling continuously since 2016, which meant many producers could no longer cover their production costs. Due to falling coffee prices, there have been efforts in the coffee industry to show the coffee value chain transparently.
By disclosing the cost distribution, the goal is to enable fair payment for all parties in the value chain. However, there has been no analysis of the concept of transparency in the coffee industry so far. Moreover, it was not examined how transparency in coffee processing could potentially be measured.
The objective of the work is on one hand to identify the most important aspects for creating transparency in the coffee value chain. On the other hand, a model should be established for analyzing transparency in the coffee value chain.

Questions Regarding Transparency
The work addresses the specialty coffee segment and answers the following questions:
- What aspects must be considered to create transparency in the specialty coffee segment?
- What approaches to creating transparency in value chains exist for the comparison product cocoa, and what can be transferred to the coffee industry?
- What can a verified model for analyzing transparency in the coffee value chain look like?
To answer the theoretical aspects of these questions, a systematic literature review was conducted. Additionally, guided interviews and a supplementary short questionnaire were used to survey roasters, the organization "the Pledge," and consumers. In this work, the following individuals were interviewed from the roasters and the organization "the Pledge":
- Mathias Bühler from Adrianos
- Andreas Felsen from Quijote Kaffee
- Christoph Sauser from Horizonte Coffee Roasters
- Fabian Schmid from Drip Roasters
- Jonas Lorenz from "the Pledge"
David Wistorf's Findings
What aspects must be considered to create transparency in the specialty coffee segment?
In answering question 1, current literature showed that the concept of transparency has neither only advantages nor disadvantages, but rather that the results of transparency must be evaluated case by case. Important measurement units for analyzing transparency in the coffee value chain so far are the FOB price and the ex-farmgate price. However, criticism of both prices was expressed in the literature and in the survey results.
The interest and focus of those surveyed clearly lies in the work and processing steps in the country of origin. The roasters interviewed consider it particularly important in a transparent value chain to receive information about farm worker wages, the ex-farmgate price, processing, drying, the FOB price, and production costs.
For a transparent value chain, the consumers interviewed consider knowledge about the payment of all parties in the country of origin, working conditions, environmental impact, water consumption in processing, roasting, and shipping and handover to be most important.

What approaches to creating transparency in value chains exist for the comparison product cocoa, and what can be transferred to the coffee industry?
To answer the second question about what aspects regarding the creation of transparency exist in cocoa production and how these can be transferred to the coffee value chain, literature has shown that in cocoa processing the focus is on disclosing what each involved party needs to live (living income).
The focus is particularly on producers, as they often receive a very small share of the retail price. In the coffee industry, the FOB price or the ex-farmgate price is frequently communicated in isolation. This is done without accompanying context as to whether these prices are high or low. Therefore, the approach from cocoa to coffee processing for determining living income can be adopted. If living income is determined and communicated in coffee, the previously communicated prices can be put into context and thus be more easily interpreted.

What can a verified model for analyzing transparency in the coffee value chain look like?
To create a verified model for analyzing transparency in the coffee value chain (question 3), the results from the guided interviews were further developed.
This resulted in a three-part model, each forming a separate result. The three parts are divided according to where value creation stands in the chain. Accordingly, three parts emerged: country of origin, logistics, and country of consumption.
These are further divided into a total of six links. These links are refined into a total of 29 steps. These steps were weighted based on the results of the guided interviews, so that if information about all steps in the corresponding value chain is available, the three results of the parts each total 100%.
When applying the model, it must be checked which steps of the corresponding value chain are known. In the next step, all weightings per step and value chain must be added together.
This produces the individual results for each part of the value chain. The higher the results, the more information is available about the coffee value chain, and accordingly, the more transparent the value chain is.
Model as a Table
Through the insights gained in this work, particularly from the model, it is possible in practice to analyze how transparent a specialty coffee value chain is. This offers the opportunity to compare different value chains and make decisions based on that.
However, the interpretation and in particular the generalization of the results must be done with caution, as on the one hand the number of roasters and consumers surveyed was small. On the other hand, due to the Corona pandemic and difficult access to producers and coffee traders, they could not be surveyed. Thus, the results of the work are only from the perspective of parties in the country of consumption. As a result, the part of the value chain up to and including logistics is not represented.
In the future, the results of the work should be verified with a larger number of respondents and the established model adjusted accordingly. Additionally, it should be examined whether the model can also be transferred to value chains of coffee under 80 quality points. Cocoa processing has shown that living income can be of great importance, as it puts transparently communicated prices into context. Future research should, against this backdrop, investigate how high the living income is for coffee producers in each region.
















