Home / Coffee knowledge / Do speculators determine the price of coffee?
    Kaffeemarkt
    Machen Spekulanten den Kaffeepreis?

    Do speculators determine the price of coffee?

    In fall 2024, coffee prices rose to record highs and remained at all-time highs throughout 2025. Why exactly? I made two videos about this and saw the origin in Brazil's poor harvest, only then in excessive speculation. (Video from January 2025) and an Update in November 2025.

    In between, I repeatedly read and heard that this unprecedented rise was the direct product of commodity speculation and that many of the sharp fluctuations could not be rationally explained.

    Attributing all the movements to "speculation" didn't feel convincing enough to me and especially not precise. Until then, I felt the word more than I understood it. I wanted to know more and embarked on an intensive learning journey.


    At the beginning of this learning journey, I really only had one question:

    • Who sets the coffee price?
    • And why does it sometimes move so sharply up or down, and even within a single day?

    I wanted to know if it's really true what you keep hearing: That speculation distorts prices. That investors drive the market. That speculation is the catalyst for upward or downward movements.

    And I also wanted to know if we're making life harder for ourselves than it needs to be. If the idea is correct that "the speculators" are to blame. Or if with this idea we're just ducking out of understanding a more complicated system.

    "Speculation is to blame!"

    Since the rise in green coffee prices on the exchange (the so-called C-Market) in November 2024, I've engaged with the topic more intensively than ever before in my coffee career. At first it was about understanding exactly what was happening, how we as a coffee roastery could orient ourselves, what it meant for producers, and how we could develop a vision together.

    And at some point I kept hearing that this was all the work of "the speculators." When the Lavazza CEO said in summer 2025 that 80% of the movement came from hedge funds, I nodded at first, but then became skeptical—and especially curious. "Speculation" doesn't really explain anything, it mainly stirs up feelings.

    "Speculation often serves people as an explanation when there's an explanation vacuum."

    So I sat down, listened, and asked questions. With people who trade coffee. With people who produce coffee. And with analysts who have observed commodity markets for decades.

    The deeper I went, the clearer it became: There is no simple story. But there are many layers.

    What is speculation? About futures, shorts and longs

    I wanted to understand the mechanics behind coffee price formation and speculation on coffee. So I spoke with Heinz Zimmermann, emeritus professor of financial market theory in Basel. He said a sentence that stayed with me later on:

    "Speculation is not the problem. Excessive speculation is the problem."

    Heinz Zimmermann Profile
    Heinz Zimmermann

    Because: Speculation serves a function. It's part of the counterparty to producers who sell futures to protect their prices against drops (to hedge against lower prices).

    An example:

    If twelve producers want to protect their harvest and sell futures (a future is a contract that stipulates someone must buy or sell a specific quantity of coffee at a specific price in the future), but only three roasters want to buy, then an imbalance arises. Speculators fill this gap. Or as Heinz Zimmermann says: "Producers want to get rid of risk. Speculators take on risk."

    When producers heavily hedge (protect themselves against falling prices) and sell futures, more open positions are created. And these must be bought. These can be so-called commercial actors, meaning traders or roasters. But if they don't buy, then speculators step in. In exchange terms, they now go long, while the hedging producers go short.

    To maintain balance here so the market actually functions, supplies need to meet demand. And speculators take on these open positions.

    How do speculators make money?

    The interest of speculators is purely monetary in nature. For them it's not about the physical product coffee, but about making financial gain.

    This gain happens when there are changes in the coffee market. Whether prices go up or down is secondary: the gain results from the change in price.

    Whoever buys at a lower price and sells higher makes a profit, as does someone who expects falling prices. Then speculators go short, selling a future at a high price that they don't yet own.

    If the price falls later, they buy the future back cheaper. Here too, the difference is the profit.

    This movement, or volatility, is the magnet for speculators. But too much volatility isn't attractive for them either, Judy Ganes told me.

    When speculation becomes too much: excessive speculation

    I wanted to know from Judy Ganes who actually speculates? Judy Ganes spent time on Wall Street and has been following commodity markets for decades, and she says:

    "Speculators are the scapegoat. Always."

    Judy Ganes Profile

    Judy Ganes

    She doesn't believe the thesis that private investment funds destroy the market. She says speculators amplify movements, but they don't create them. Everything begins in the cash market, in physical reality.

    Aside: the cash market: Here actual, physically available green coffee is traded. In contrast to the futures market, the cash market is about immediate delivery and actual demand today, not in the future.

    Judy explains further that speculation can be an amplification of already existing trends. And at the same time, I see it through Heinz Zimmermann's lens: Amplification is not harmless. Amplification can cause more damage than the trigger itself.

    If a frost threatens, that's a so-called fundamental factor. But if billions flow into the market within minutes because algorithms detect a correlation, then the market hasn't just reacted, it's overreacted.

    Heinz puts it soberly: "Volatility is higher than what would be fundamentally necessary." And that's the point where speculation becomes excessive speculation.

    How volatility feels at the coffee origin

    César Marin

    Volatility, the constantly changing state, is interesting to a certain extent for speculators on one side. Roasters become hesitant when buying, because a small price shift can have a large impact on order placement for a customer. For producers, meanwhile, volatility is a nerve-wracking and tearing test.

    The coffee is about to be harvested or has just been harvested. But at what price do I as a producer sell the coffee now? More precisely: When do I sell it if the price constantly changes? And who buys it when?

    Many producers in recent months were ready to sell coffee, but buyers didn't want to buy. So it happened, César Marin reports in the podcast, that producers had two harvests on hand and waited until someone would buy their coffee.

    César also says that the coffee price determines whether a producer in Peru can finance their harvest. It determines whether a cooperative loses loyal members or a whole region gets new buyers who show up with cash that nobody expected.

    Miguel leads Ensambles projects throughout Mexico

    Miguel Guevara

    The high volatility is difficult for all participants in the coffee chain because it doesn't allow long-term planning without a lot of risk.

    Miguel Guevara from our partners at Ensambles in Mexico assesses the situation for small producers like this:

    "The cherry people spend every day checking the exchange."

    The producers who sell coffee in cherries check the New York coffee price every day. "Every day." Producers who sell their coffee in parchment live in a different time axis. There, prices are adjusted more slowly, volatility arrives muted. "But it always comes."

    a hand with parchment

    Excessive speculation and the resulting volatility doesn't just rapidly change the macro level and the C-Price, it changes the pace at which people on the ground make decisions. But above all, it creates uncertainty: Whether producers sell today or tomorrow and whether they remain loyal to a cooperative or not.

    And that's a stark contrast:

    On one side we have market participants making short-term decisions at a screen, but their effect impacts thousands of kilometers away in coffee countries. What's striking is that a decision at the screen is made quickly, but agriculture is slow. It takes three years for a coffee tree to bear fruit at all. So two completely different worlds stand opposite each other, but are connected through the coffee market.

    "Coffee doesn't wait"

    One of the sentences that stuck with me on this journey came from producer and friend César Marin from Peru. He said: "El café no espera." Coffee doesn't wait.

    When I heard that, I didn't yet know how central this sentence would become. But it suddenly stood representative for everything that can happen in the coffee market when prices rise or fall in the shortest time.

    César told me how it was in his region around Villa Rica in 2025. The harvest was there, the coffee cherries were ripe, but nobody wanted to buy.

    "There was coffee," he says. "But nobody bought coffee."

    Producers had picked and processed coffee, but there were no buyers because collection centers in the region were closed. And so there was this stalemate: The sellers (the producers) wanted to sell coffee because prices were high. The buyers (e.g. the collection centers) didn't want to buy coffee because the price was too high for them.

    At the same time, new buyers suddenly appeared who nobody knew who they represented. Collection centers that paid 450 to 470 cts/lb per pound of parchment—these were never-before-seen prices. César says: "I believe these were companies from Colombia, Honduras and Brazil." Companies, in other words, that couldn't buy enough coffee from their own markets and therefore came to Peru to meet their demand.

    Why the industry can't just watch

    I also spoke with people who buy coffee in large quantities: the procurement director of a large European retailer, as well as the green coffee buyer for one of Europe's largest roasteries. When it comes to volumes, the leverage up and down is greater.

    "Volatility can destroy your accounting," says the procurement director.

    "If you buy 20,000 tons of coffee and the price fluctuates twenty or thirty cents in a short time, that's millions of dollars." The green coffee buyer confirms this statement:

    "There are always winners and losers. But the problem is not the price. The problem is the speed."

    He gave me this example: If competitor A makes a green coffee contract at 4.25 USD/lb (approximately 9.37 USD/kg) and competitor B buys at 4.10 USD/lb and the competitor is at 4.00 USD/lb (approximately 9.04 USD/kg), then that determines competitiveness and thus the allocation of orders.

    The industry tries to adapt. Procurement now sits much more closely with sales and the finance department. And the customer themselves is also included in the planning.

    The sharp fluctuations and high prices have meant that there's more money in the market than ever before. Traders too are reaching their limits, since in their commercial function they first buy coffee and later sell it. They also borrow money for that. Money supplies have increased massively since November 2024. David Neumann also comments on this in this podcast episode.

    Why speculation is necessary—but remains dangerous at the same time

    After this long journey, I don't stand here and say: Speculation is the problem. But I do say: Excessive speculation is a problem. And a serious one at that.

    Speculation is necessary so producers can hedge their prices. Without speculators there would be no functioning futures market. But when capital inflows become too large, when models blindly amplify trends, when liquidity doesn't stabilize but accelerates, then producers, traders, cooperatives and also roasters become extras in a market that moves faster than any real decision.

    It's often said that the market is always right. I would say: The market always has a result. But whether it's right shows itself only later.

    And this "later" is often the next harvest.

    What do you think?