Home / Coffee knowledge / Coffee Reality Checks. Why exactly should specialty coffee be better?
    Blog
    Coffee Reality Checks. Warum genau soll Spezialitätenkaffee besser sein?

    Coffee Reality Checks. Why exactly should specialty coffee be better?

    What is the conviction based on that specialty coffee is so much better in many respects? To explain specialty coffee, we often use average coffee as a reference and point out the differences. But to formulate the differences precisely, one must first understand average coffee.

    My first specialty espresso contained 10% Robusta. This would probably not pass as a specialty everywhere today. Not only have definitions become stricter, sometimes I get the feeling that in the specialty coffee world there is a drastic rejection of anything that is not "different", "artisan", "speciality", "direct trade", or "micro". Unfortunately, these are neither compulsory quality criteria nor explanations. They are often just buzzwords that apparently don't need to be explained because it's so easy to hide behind them.

    Yet these very designations offer a good starting point to explain the differences to average coffee. But you have to know average coffee to avoid dismissing plus or minus 90% of the market.

    It's probably not worthwhile in the long run to point out differences by disparaging coffee varieties, certain countries of origin, companies, etc. Rather, we should understand the consumer and their quality standards.

    Criteria such as harmonious, mild, fine, strong, intense, elegant, distinguished, and a nice crema, we search for in vain on the standardized SCA rating sheets. Their explanatory value is limited. But they mean a lot in the language of the uninitiated, so we should take them up and expand on them. That might also mean that we should drink pretty much every kind of coffee at some point.

    Reality Check 1: The great espresso at the Italian highway rest stop

    We know that coffee in Italy tastes good to many people. There are reasons for this. But has each of us also drunk such espressos and objectively analyzed the sensory attributes the way you would with a score sheet à la SCAA? Most coffees possess some attribute that scores better than the others. We need to understand what these are and why they convince the average coffee drinker. My idea? Syrupy consistency and "intensity".

    Reality Check 2: Robusta

    Ever done a Robusta cupping? If not, why not? It's high time, because the still widespread 70/30 Arabica-Robusta ratio myth needs to give way to reality. Demand, climate change, and politics mean that today we have a tight 55/45 ratio. Projections suggest that in at most ten years we will have more Robusta than Arabica on the market. The economic and natural conditions of many coffee farmers today limit a rapid increase in more specialty coffee.

    Moreover, Robusta farmers are also coffee farmers. If the story goes that higher prices for good quality help coffee farmers, then one should think the story through to the end and include Robusta farmers in the narrative. In a few years they will form the majority of coffee producers. One should probably face reality and engage with Robusta again. After all, there are many consumers who like it. Very many, in fact.

    Reality Check 3: Dark roasts and defects

    Roasting philosophies are a sensitive topic. Just this much: lighter doesn't necessarily have to be better, underdeveloped doesn't taste particularly good, and there's more to coffee than just acidity. Those who offer such coffees probably have more difficulty reaching average coffee drinkers. They have become accustomed to roasting aromas, and these don't always have to be bad. Especially when they mask defects. And these are reality too. Commercial Turkish coffee has many defects and is roasted very dark. But in doing so, it has a highly recognizable flavor profile. Many coffee drinkers have also gotten used to this. To understand them, you also have to understand Turkish coffee.

    Reality checks help us not to get carried away and to take certain things a bit more lightly. If we listen to consumers and convey our learned knowledge in their language, we'll probably reach more of them.

    What do you think?

      Which machine should we test next?

      Espresso machine or grinder: Tell us what should be next on our test bench. We read every request.

      We only use your email to follow up on your request. You'll only receive the newsletter if you check the box and confirm. Privacy Policy