Milk is not just milk. Worlds can lie between one milk and another. And we're not talking about taste, fat content or price, but about its impact on our environment.
In our cafés, more than 70% of coffee drinks are prepared with milk. That's approximately six times more milk than coffee. For this reason alone, milk is just as much in focus for us as the Kaffeemacher.
Are we allowed to drink milk? This question is suitable for opening an extensive ethical discussion. The article should focus less on ethics, animal welfare or nutritional physiology (you'll find more leading links at the end of the article), but rather deals mainly with climate impact.
To do this, we want to present two perspectives. One leads to the result: cows are climate killers. The other paints a different picture. But why does cow's milk have such a high social standing in the first place, and why is the climate impact of cows so high in global emissions?

What is milk?
Milk exists whenever a mammal has offspring. Without offspring, no milk. When we drink milk other than mother's milk, we are always drinking the milk of an infant. So without a lamb, no sheep's milk, without a puppy, no dog milk, without a baby, no mother's milk, and without a calf, no milk. Cow's milk is so important <1> that it is the only milk that doesn't require the name of the animal. This is also anchored in law: within the EU, only milk from cows can be called "milk" in trade.
After the nursing period (breastfeeding), lactase production normally stops in all mammals. Without lactase, milk proteins can no longer be broken down and thus milk can no longer be processed in the body. Humans are the exception. They are the only mammals that can consume milk and dairy products after infancy. Today, approximately one-third of the world's population is only lactose intolerant. How did this come about?
A new study explains: livestock farming began as soon as people settled down. The milk was reserved for offspring. Especially during famines, people were then forced to resort to animal milk. In times of malnutrition and scarcity, intolerances usually led to death, and thus the "lactose tolerant" prevailed. So cattle gradually became livestock rather than a work animal.
From the 1960s onwards, we speak for the first time of industrial livestock farming as we know it today. The term promised supply security at the time and had a positive connotation.
To date, there are approximately 950 million cattle <2>, of which approximately 260 million are dairy cows <3>. Per capita milk consumption in Germany in 2022 was 46.1 kg. (The trend is declining) <4>.
Status Quo

A look at the list of climate-damaging foods shows that the top three places belong to the cow. Butter, beef and dairy products (cream, milk and cheese) rank highest. <5>. This suggests that a world without cows would be better.
The milk system
Conventionally produced milk (and dairy products) perform particularly poorly in terms of climate impact. This is because even the cultivation of concentrated feed, which is largely imported from overseas, causes deforestation there and releases large amounts of stored carbon. The imposed monocultures require large amounts of fertilizer. Fertilizer production is resource-intensive and produces large quantities of CO₂. When applied, significant amounts of nitrous oxide can be produced. (Nitrous oxide is particularly harmful because it has 300 times the climate impact compared to CO₂). The transport of concentrated feed to Europe creates additional CO₂. With the transported plants, stored nitrogen also comes to Europe and over-fertilizes the fields in the form of cow manure. This creates depletion in cultivation and over-fertilization in Europe. Both lead to measures that end with more carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. A vicious cycle for soils and the climate.
In addition, the cow itself produces large amounts of methane during food processing (approximately 550 L per day; methane is in turn approximately 28 times more harmful to the climate than CO₂). Thus, methane emissions from "the cow" account for approximately 48% of agricultural emissions in Germany in 2022.<6>
Depending on the type of farming, emissions in Germany are therefore 0.9 kg CO2e (organic pasture farming, with allocation of meat sales) to 1.64 kg CO2e (conventional farming without grazing, without allocation) <7>, but the global average is 2.4 kg CO2e per liter of milk <8>.
Emissions (global average) are roughly equivalent to the emissions produced when burning one liter of gasoline. (Tank-to-wheel assessment → so just the combustion, without extraction)
Is 1 liter of milk as harmful as 1 liter of gasoline?
Are there solutions?
There are various approaches, from increasing milk yield to feed additives that reduce methane emissions. <9>
One solution would be to increase milk yield while keeping methane emissions constant. A hundred years ago, a cow's milk yield was approximately 2000 liters per year; today it's around 8000 liters. (These are values from cows that have been bred for milk production. For dual-purpose breeds, the values are lower. With our dairy farmer, for example, the cows produce about 4000L per year.) If we calculate the daily methane emissions of a cow, approximately 550 L (which in turn corresponds to ~400 g), based on annual milk yield.* Then milk from a hundred years ago had a carbon footprint of 2.05 kg CO₂ equivalents, compared to 0.51 kg CO2e today. If feed additives are added that promise a one-third reduction in methane, it would only be 0.34 kg CO2e. This would correspond to a reduction of almost 84%. However, this calculation regularly makes an error – only the output is considered.
The cow from a hundred years ago very probably only ate grass from pasture, whereas the cow today has to receive the concentrated feed described above to achieve such yields. Feed additives also have to be manufactured, processed, shipped, and added to the feed.
Is the cow from a hundred years ago probably the more sustainable one? And might the solution lie not in technological progress, but in the form of farming?
The climate killer... or not?
In many assessments, the cow is viewed as a milk machine and its emissions are allocated to the final product just like those of machines. These machines can be optimized, output increased and emissions reduced. All technical optimization for a living creature. We want to show you another perspective.
Change of perspective
Every human being emits CO₂, just as with the cow, we metabolize our food and emit CO₂ in the process (and also methane). This may only be a small part (between 168 and 2040 kilograms of carbon dioxide per year; <10>
Comparison of CO₂ equivalents of methane from dairy cows and CO₂ from humanity
Assumption 1: 8 billion people; each emits an average of 1.1 t CO₂ per year through breathing
Assumption 2: 260 million dairy cows; each emits approximately 400 g of methane per day; methane's greenhouse effect is 28 times higher than that of CO₂. Thus the average CO2e emission is 4.1 t CO₂ from methane excretion.
Accordingly, humanity emits 8.8 billion t CO₂ while dairy cows "only" emit 1.07 billion t CO2e from their methane output. (If you also include cattle from meat production, the output would be 14.98 billion t CO2e)
(The breathing of cows and methane emissions from humans are missing here)

Both our breathing and the methane emissions from cows are part of the carbon cycle. Methane breaks down into CO₂ and hydrogen. This CO₂ is taken up by plants, which store the carbon and release oxygen back into the atmosphere.
Cows provide us with proteins and carbohydrates that would otherwise not be available to us. We can digest corn and soy ourselves, but not grass.
Where do we get our milk from?
We source our milk from Jonas Plattner. He operates a small-scale organic milk production farm in Reigoldswil in Switzerland.
The farm
- Jonas lets his cows graze on 30 hectares of land
- He owns 15 cows and 1 bull
The cows
- The cows are a dual-purpose breed: they produce less milk but slightly more meat when they are older
- Jonas' cows live to be about 15 years old, which is very old in milk production
- The bull is part of the cow herd
- The cows give milk twice a day, totaling about 10 liters per cow
- In one week, the cows produce about 900 liters
The food
- The cows eat only grass; hay in winter
- Concentrated feed such as soy or corn is not used; Jonas also forgoes silage
Farming practices make the difference - Regenerative agriculture
We all know that trees bind CO₂. But much more important for our climate are soils: forest soils, meadows and moors. Technical solutions in the fight against climate warming imitate what nature has already solved.
With industrial livestock farming, more and more animals were kept on less and less land. This allowed the remaining land to be used to grow feed. As described, however, this leads to depletion in one place and over-fertilization in another.
But when cattle return to pastures, they can provide additional carbon sequestration and make these pastures, which are unsuitable as arable land, available for human nutrition. For ideal carbon sequestration, they must be kept in short intervals in small grazing areas, so that in this small area grass can be grazed and cow manure can be used as fertilizer (mob grazing). After that, this area remains at rest for a certain time to recover. This promotes root growth before the cattle are allowed to graze on it again.
No grassland without grazers.
If you calculate the carbon sequestration that can occur this way against the emissions, the overall balance of cows looks completely different. Unfortunately, there are few studies on this. One of them is from "White Oak Pastures," <11> which concludes that for every kilogram of meat, approximately 1.6 kg of CO₂ is stored in the soils.

Conclusion
Back to milk. We have it in our own hands; we can choose for our needs at home: do we support the status quo, do we turn to alternatives like oats, or do we choose the regenerative option. Two out of three options tend to have positive climate effects. That sounds good. (The fact is, however, that the real share is (still) small.)
In Germany, there are around 100 farms that produce milk not only regeneratively but also in retention farming. The special thing about this is that the calves grow up with their mother and are allowed to drink first, and humans get what "is left over." The organic share of all milk produced is approximately 3.5%, of which approximately 2% is cow-calf rearing. <12>
As citizens, we reject industrial livestock farming, but as consumers we still don't.

Further reading:
- TED Talk Allan Savory
-
TED Talk Bobby Gill
- Farm Rebellion on Disney+ - Trailer
- NDR Green Garage - Beef enjoyment without qualms?
- The Milk System on Netflix - Trailer
- ARTE Documentary: What are we still allowed to eat?
Books
- The Cow is not a Climate Killer! - Anita Idel
- Rebels of the Earth: how we save the soil - and ourselves! - Benedikt Bösel
- Holistic Management Handbook - Allan Savory
Sources:
<1> cf.: statista.com, Milk - Germany, as of: 28.09.23
<2> cf.: https://de.statista.com/statistik/daten/studie/28931/umfrage/weltweiter-rinderbestand-seit-1990/, as of: 28.09.23
<3> cf.: agrarheute.de, Dairy farming XXL: Herd size growing worldwide , as of: 28.09.23
<4> cf.: tagesschau.de, Why Germans drink less milk, as of: 28.09.23
<5> cf.: utopia.de, These 6 foods are worst for the climate , as of: 28.09.23
<6> cf.: umweltbundesamt.de, Contribution of agriculture to greenhouse gas emissions, as of: 28.09.23
<7> cf.: umweltbundesamt, Making hidden environmental costs of agriculture visible using the example of milk production systems, as of: 28.09.23
<8> cf.: bauernverband.de, Methane emissions in cattle farming, as of: 28.09.23
<9> cf.: dsm.com, The proven solution for methane reduction, as of: 28.09.23
<10> cf.: co2online.de, What does a human breathe out, as of: 28.09.23
<11> cf.: whiteoakpastures.com, Study: White Oak Pastures Beef Reduces Atmospheric Carbon , as of: 28.09.23
<12> cf.: ardmediathek.de, Content , as of: 28.09.23
















