Home / Coffee knowledge / SCA points and the impact on coffee cooperatives
    Blog
    SCA Punkte und die Auswirkungen für Kaffeegenossenschaften

    SCA points and the impact on coffee cooperatives

    A few weeks ago, an article was posted about the rampant use of SCA scoring. The article interested me because so far little has been reported about the impact of this scoring system on producer organizations. I have been speaking with representatives of coffee cooperatives about the SCA points system for some time, and they have been observing a development that is threatening to them for years.

    Guest contribution by Kleber Cruz, green coffee buyer for Gepa. Kleber Cruz regularly writes interesting articles with many insights from work in cooperatives and coffee-growing countries such as Peru, Mexico, Honduras and Nicaragua. In the future, we will publish Kleber's texts on Kaffeemacher.ch to make this important content accessible to a wider audience. Thank you so much for your work, Kleber!

    Cooperatives' Investment in Quality Improvement for Members

    Over the years, many cooperatives have invested in improving the quality of their members' coffee and have achieved quite high standards. Manuel Quiliche from the COPICAFE cooperative in Peru tells me what his cooperative has invested to continuously improve varieties. In doing so, the cooperative has also built a social foundation that makes it easier to carry out certain projects, such as joint marketing and processing of coffee. I hear the same thing from Nicaragua, Jinotega, to be more precise, when I speak with Alvaro Rodriguez (representative of the coffee cooperative COASSAN): "At the end of the 90s and with the price crisis, a program began in Nicaragua to identify quality coffee and differentiate it. This work was led and guided by cooperatives, at the time the advantage was that they had already organized producers, this circumstance greatly facilitated the implementation of this project". Leonid Herrera from the Jose Olaya Coop in Peru comments: "Over the years, the cooperatives have introduced new organic farming techniques, offered producers much relief for this transition, such as access to credit, advances for harvest, transport of their products, provision of biofertilizer, or renewal of coffee plants, but above all further education seminars". Through this work of the cooperatives, members of the organizations were able to significantly improve the quality of their coffee over the years. The work of the cooperatives was crucial for many producers to achieve a good quality level. But as always, this process does not reach all producers.

    foto kleber

    Importers Bypass Cooperatives

    There are some importers who have purchased coffee directly from cooperatives in the past. Through these relationships, they were able to learn more about the work in the field and better understand the entire production process and identify growing areas of good coffee. However, for some time there has been a concerning development for cooperatives: Importers who previously bought from cooperatives now go directly to producers who, thanks to the work of cooperatives, have achieved a high standard, and buy from them coffees of outstanding quality (86+ SCA or higher). This is coffee from high growing areas. For this coffee, importers pay prices that are sometimes more than 50% higher than cooperative prices. For the cooperatives, coffees from low and medium altitude zones remain, which are good, but far from achieving scores above 86. Hugo Roblero, responsible for exports in his organization FEJCEM cooperative in Mexico, also tells me: "Buyers in Mexico come to the most remote communities and buy the best coffees directly from producers at higher prices that the cooperative cannot compete with. This practice destabilizes us, the farmers are unhappy with us, and we lack these extremely good coffees to achieve better prices."

    Q-Graders Going Astray

    However, the cooperatives are observing another problem: Improving a cooperative's marketing structure also involves further training of its staff, including Q-graders, and equipping coffee laboratories. The cooperatives have invested a great deal in this area. Now these Q-graders are responsible for coffee quality in the cooperatives. Some of them have discovered the business gap and are splitting off from the cooperatives. That is, these Q-graders identified farmers who have good coffees and are dissatisfied with the cooperative, quit the cooperatives, organize these farmers in parallel companies, sell the high-quality coffee directly to the importer or to consumer countries, and achieve good prices.

    In this development, the problem for the organizations is that they have invested in improving commercial infrastructure for years and have achieved good quality standards. Now they see their sales opportunities decimated because of these practices. Many cooperatives consider this unfair.

    What Prevents Cooperatives from Acting Differently Themselves?

    However, the legitimate question arises: why can't cooperatives compete with these specialty coffee importers? One point is certainly that change processes in cooperatives can only proceed very slowly and laboriously. Market adjustments take longer for cooperatives than for other business forms, which I believe is a major problem that cooperatives have not yet properly addressed. Another point is undoubtedly that these organizational structures are sometimes misused for other purposes.

    But the current market conditions for coffee cooperatives are also unfavorable: The prices paid for specialty coffees or microlots are decoupled from commodity prices, while coffee cooperatives are dependent on the NY exchange price. Leonid tells me: "The market doesn't help, the price for coffee quoted on the New York Stock Exchange is much lower than production costs." The costs of supplies and tools have become expensive, prices for equipment and infrastructure for organic conversion are constantly rising. Under these conditions, the economic efficiency of cooperatives is not sufficient to compete with importers/buyers of specialty coffees or microlots.

    Every Coffee Needs a Market

    On the other hand, the market for specialty coffees in consumer countries is still so small that it cannot keep pace with the rampant development in producing countries worldwide. Coffees are offered as specialty or microlots that actually are not. In fact, cooperatives have a wide range of coffee available in all qualities. They must try to sell everything, that is, the entire assortment. From these sales, they usually calculate an average price, which they pass on to producers minus costs. This model means that farmers who have delivered top quality receive less than specialty coffee buyers would pay them. Farmers who delivered low quality can achieve better income through this pricing policy. Other organizations are trying to introduce different price models, but cooperative price models try to achieve a balance between producers. This model proved itself during quarantine, due to COVID-19: Without the cooperatives, the situation in rural areas would be more dramatic than it already is.

    Perspective: Improving Coffee Quality in "Lowland Coffees"

    However, it appears that producers of good coffees have for some time been unwilling to accept this model and are putting pressure on the cooperatives; the cooperative cannot exclude farmers, though. Leonid tells me: "Cooperatives cannot afford to discriminate against farmers, but we demand that they continue to train themselves. They should constantly improve their craft, design their investments so that the family ultimately benefits, they should not switch to growing illegal products like coca."

    A manager of a cooperative in northern Peru also tells me of his concern that his members are beginning to sell their best coffees outside the cooperatives. According to him, it is necessary to continuously improve the quality of lowland coffees. But for this to happen, there also needs to be a market that helps with better prices.

    What do you think?

      Which machine should we test next?

      Espresso machine or grinder: Tell us what should be next on our test bench. We read every request.

      We only use your email to follow up on your request. You'll only receive the newsletter if you check the box and confirm. Privacy Policy