Home / Coffee knowledge / Espresso Grinder Test Protocol: How we test
    Espressomühlen
    Testprotokoll Espressomühlen: So testen wir

    Espresso Grinder Test Protocol: How we test

    Espresso grinder test protocol: How we test

    Over the past few years, we have tested over 90 espresso grinders – from entry-level machines at €150 to professional single-dosing grinders above €1,000. What emerged from this is not guesswork, but a structured measurement and test protocol that we have continuously refined with each test.

    This article explains how we proceed, why we measure exactly these values, and what lies behind our rating thresholds. It also serves as a reference for all of our individual grinder reports – we link to the relevant sections here.

    Test protocol overview

    Our test is divided into four blocks, which are conducted at staggered intervals. This ensures that we capture both the cold start of a grinder and its behavior after break-in and under load.

    All grinders are tested with the same coffee: the Apas Espresso, a natural-processed Brazilian from our partner cooperative APAS. Same coffee, same bean batch – this creates comparability across all grinders.

    Block 1 – Break-in and initial assessment: Accessory check, grind 1 kg of coffee, initial recipe setting, first particle distribution samples.

    Block 2 – Main measurements: Temperature, volume, grind speed, consistency check, further particle samples with and without RDT (Ross Droplet Technique).

    Block 3 – Adjustment check: Ristretto, lungo, reset to espresso – how does the grinder behave with significant grind size changes?

    Block 4 – Retention: Absolute, temporary and permanent retention are measured precisely.

    Tastings take place in parallel with the respective blocks and conclude with blind tasting.

    Starting material and break-in

    Before we take a single measurement, we grind 1 kg of coffee through the grinder. This simulates realistic use and ensures that flour and oils have broken in in the grinder. A freshly unboxed grinder behaves differently than one that has 200 shots behind it – and we test the latter.

    We then check the included accessories: dosing cup, funnel, brush, key. We note what is included. We also note what is missing.

    For the in-out test, we grind 18 g of coffee three times for 30 seconds each and measure the output amount. This gives us an initial assessment of retention and consistency – before any other measurements.

    Volume

    We measure volume with a calibrated sound meter, positioned 20 cm from the grinder. Measurement is taken during continuous grinding of 250 g of coffee – not during cold start, but during steady-state operation.

    Rating Decibels
    Top / quiet below 80 dB
    Medium / rather loud 80–90 dB
    Negative / loud above 90 dB

    Why these thresholds? 80 dB is roughly the noise of a vacuum cleaner at normal distance – this is the point at which a grinder is perceived as disruptive in a quiet kitchen. Above 90 dB, at lawn mower level, it's simply too loud for home use. Below 80 dB, however – like the Mazzer Philos at 78.1 dB – a grinder is acceptable even early in the morning or in an open kitchen.

    Important: Grinding sound has two dimensions. The raw decibel number says little about the quality of the noise. A penetrating, high-pitched whining sound at 73 dB (like the Varia VS3) can subjectively seem more disruptive than steady humming at 78 dB. We document such qualitative impressions in the notes.

    Grinding temperature

    Heat is the invisible enemy of good extraction. Coffee ground too hot loses volatile aromatics even before extraction – and fats begin to oxidize. We measure the temperature of the grinds immediately after grinding, five times in succession with 18 g each and 20 seconds pause between to show the heating effect.

    Rating Temperature of grinds
    Top below 30 °C
    Good 30.1–35 °C
    Medium / warm 35.1–39 °C
    Negative / very warm above 39 °C

    Why these thresholds? Below 30 °C, the grinds are still near room temperature – no measurable thermal stress. From 35 °C onwards, we occasionally taste differences in tastings, especially with light, aromatic delicate roasts. Above 39 °C, as we measured on the Zuriga G2 at 40.2 °C, is a real limitation: it disqualifies the grinder for higher throughputs because temperature continues to rise with multiple consecutive shots.

    Grinding speed

    Speed is measured in two different ways, which reveal different things and are not directly proportionally comparable.

    Measurement A – grams in 10 seconds (full hopper): The grinder runs with a full bean container. Measurement is of how many grams are dispensed in 10 seconds. This measurement is particularly relevant for grinders designed for hopper operation – it shows maximum performance potential and helps assess whether a grinder could also be suitable for commercial use.

    Rating Grams in 10 seconds
    Top above 40 g
    Good 30.1–40 g
    Medium 20.1–30 g
    Slow 10–20 g
    Very slow below 10 g

    Measurement B – time for 18 g: With hopper grinders, this measurement is also performed with a full hopper – the value thus stands in direct proportion to the 10-second measurement. With single-dosing grinders, measurement is taken with an empty hopper. This also includes the time for additional taps with the air blower needed to fully expel the coffee. The total duration is therefore somewhat longer and not directly comparable to hopper values.

    Rating Time for 18 g
    Top 1–6 seconds
    Good 6.1–10 seconds
    Medium 10.1–15 seconds
    Slow 15.1–20 seconds
    Very slow above 20 seconds

    Why is speed relevant? Very fast grinders grind under high pressure, which raises grinding temperature. Very slow grinders extend the contact time of coffee with the burrs – this doesn't have to be a weakness, but it does significantly change workflow. If you wait 60 seconds in the morning, you notice it.

    Retention

    Retention is the area in a grinder where already ground coffee remains. This coffee is not immediately dispensed, but only on the next grind – so it is always slightly older than freshly ground coffee. The larger the retention, the stronger the flavor consequences: rancid, sharp, unbalanced. We describe this in detail in our article on retention.

    We distinguish three types: Temporary retention empties and fills with each grind – it is the dominant factor for everyday quality. Permanent retention remains stuck permanently in cracks, around the burrs or behind the flapper and influences the aroma climate in the grinder. Absolute retention is the sum of both.

    For measurement, we remove all removable parts, brush out the grinder completely and weigh the residues.

    Rating Absolute retention
    Excellent 0–2 g
    Good / low 2.1–3.5 g
    Medium 3.6–5 g
    High 5.1–9 g
    Very high above 9 g

    Why these thresholds? At 18 g portion size, 9 g retention is almost half the espresso – half fresh, half old. You can taste that. Below 2 g the impact on the result is minor, as long as you grind regularly. Grinders in this range – like the Niche Zero (1.1 g) or the Varia VS3 (1.1 g) – are especially good for single dosing and for switching between different coffee varieties.

    Additionally, we measure single-dosing performance: how much coffee remains if you put in exactly 18 g and run the grinder for 30 seconds?

    Rating Deviation
    Top 0–0.15 g
    Good 0.16–0.3 g
    Medium 0.31–0.6 g
    Poor 0.61–1 g
    Very poor above 1 g

    Adjustment check: How consistent is the grinder?

    A grinder that cannot find its exact starting point after a large grind size adjustment is a real problem for anyone who uses multiple recipes or coffee varieties. We test this with a standardized sequence:

    1. Espresso (starting recipe): 18 g in, 45 g out, ~25 seconds
    2. Ristretto: 18 g in, 18 g out, 25 seconds
    3. Lungo / Café Crème: 18 g in, 120 g out, 25 seconds
    4. Return to espresso: 18 g in, 45 g out, 25 seconds

    From each of these points we take a 25 g sample for particle distribution measurement. This shows us not only whether the grinder finds its way back, but also how the grinds physically change with very fine and very coarse settings. The deviation of the x50 value between T4 (espresso) and T7 (espresso after reset) is a precise indicator of grind size reproducibility.

    Particle distribution

    This is the core of our scientific analysis, and here our protocol differs from most other grinder comparisons. We analyze all samples in collaboration with the Coffee Excellence Center at ZHAW (Zurich University of Teacher Education) using a Retsch Camsizer X2 – a high-precision device for dynamic image analysis.

    All samples are divided using a sample splitter to prevent separation between fine and coarse particles. Up to seven samples per grinder are measured: factory condition, espresso, ristretto, lungo, return espresso – and where possible also a slow-feeding comparison.

    x50 (median particle size): The point at which 50% of the grinds are smaller and 50% are larger. For espresso, it typically ranges between 150 and 350 µm, depending on the grinder and setting. It describes the "average grind size" and shifts finer or coarser with adjustment. On its own, however, it is only of limited significance – it describes the middle, not the edges.

    Fine fraction (Qf <100 µm): The percentage of particles smaller than 100 µm – the actual coffee dust fraction. A high fine fraction increases body and density in an espresso, but carries the risk of over-extraction and bitterness. It also forces you to grind coarser to get a flowing shot at all. Grinders with few fines can be set much finer and often deliver clearer, more nuanced flavor profiles.

    60% coarse peak width (main peak width): The size range in which 60% of the coarse particles (above 100 µm) are contained. A narrow distribution means that most particles are similar in size – even extraction, balanced flavor. A broad distribution means heterogeneity: while some particles are already over-extracting, others fall far short. In our tests, we have observed: once the peak width exceeds ~300 µm, espressos often taste "unfocused" – acidity and bitterness stand side by side unconnected, the sweetness is missing. We describe this in detail in the article on particle distribution.

    Consistency check

    A good grinder grinds precisely not just on the first shot – it does so on the fifteenth as well. For the consistency measurement, we grind 15 × 18 g with 30-second intervals and measure each output amount to 0.1 g precision. We then calculate mean and standard deviation.

    Standard deviations around 0.1 g are solid. Below 0.05 g is excellent. Above 0.2 g begins to disrupt workflow – if you dose to 0.1 g precision, you need a grinder that holds that too.

    For grinders with grind-by-weight function (such as the Eureka Libra 65 AP or Zuriga G2 GbW), we additionally check how precisely the scale works and how it handles grind size changes.

    Espresso tasting protocol

    All the measurements in the world cannot replace the decisive test: how does the espresso taste? We taste in parallel with each test phase and conduct a blind tasting at the end, in which all tested grinders are evaluated side by side.

    Our tasting protocol is based on the scoring sheet of the World Barista Championship, but we have expanded the scale to 10 points and divided the attributes more differentiated. We evaluate two dimensions:

    Flavor balance includes sweetness (balancing, indicates extraction evenness), acidity (clarity, transparency, liveliness – not sharpness) and bitterness (integrated and positive vs. harsh and disruptive).

    Tactile experience includes weight (heaviness in the mouth, independent of quality), texture (creamy, oily, silky, dusty – the quality of the weight) and aftertaste (length and quality after swallowing).

    Each evaluation is supplemented by a free description. More on this in the Espresso tasting protocol.

    RPM setting (rotation speed)

    Not all grinders offer variable speed control – when available, it is treated as a separate data point in the test. The rotation speed of the burrs influences the ratio of fine dust to coarse particles without the grind size needing to be adjusted.

    At higher rotation speed, beans are shattered with more kinetic energy, which creates more fragmentation and thus more fines. At lower rotation speed, comminution is more controlled. The consequences in the cup are noticeable: Low RPM deliver a narrower main peak in the particle curve, clearer aromas and more transparency – but less body. High RPM produce more fine dust, more body and denser texture, but also increase the risk of uneven extraction.

    RPM setting is thus a tool for flavor control that works independently of grind size – particularly valuable for single-dosing grinders like the DF64V, Lagom P64 or Varia VS6. It can help settle a frayed extraction profile through lower rotation speed, or produce a more body-forward espresso by increasing rotation speed.

    Example Varia VS6: The VS6 offers stepless control between 500 and 1,600 rpm. At 500 rpm, the particle curve shows a narrower main peak – the grinds are more homogeneous, the cup appears clearer. At 1,600 rpm, the peak noticeably widens; in espresso there is more body, sometimes but also less even extraction. If a grinder offers RPM setting, we document at least two settings with separate particle samples and tastings.

    What the protocol does not evaluate

    A good test protocol also defines its limits.

    Design and feel do not factor into the measurements. A well-crafted grinder doesn't get a point bonus from us for that – but if you spend €1,000, you can expect no plastic parts to rattle, and we note that in the comments.

    Long-term behavior we cannot capture within our testing framework. Our old Mazzer grinders have been running for 15+ years – that is experiential knowledge, not a test result.

    Filter coffee we only test where a grinder is explicitly marketed as all-purpose. Some grinders, like the Eureka Libra 65 AP, surprise positively in this regard.

    All espresso grinders in the test

    All results at a glance can be found in our large espresso grinder comparison.

    What do you think?