Intro
I'm standing in front of the fish counter at the supermarket. Half of the fish, mussels, oysters and lobsters on display are certified in one way or another. The labels are almost exclusively blue and green, bearing the keywords "fair", "responsible" and "friends" in their names and giving me a good feeling, which is the intention.
But I'm confused:
which label is exactly good now?
Or are they all?
And what does "fair fish" mean for a dead animal?
More and more questions arise and with them a lack of understanding that makes me uncertain, then critical and ultimately suspicious. So I don't buy anything - because I don't eat seafood - but also because I get the feeling that I don't have a clear picture here. I simply lack the background.
Fortunately, I work with Kaffeemacher and things are much clearer with labels - or actually not really.
Because the Kaffeemacher shelf in the supermarket, which I scan from time to time to get a feel for the pulse of the times, unfortunately looks only slightly more organized.
Labels are actually a heuristic, a shortcut to quickly grasp facts,
Anja Schröder, an expert in sustainability communication, told me in a podcast. Actually, she says, because the multitude of labels can often overwhelm. Because the use of buzzwords like fair, direct, organic and sustainable has become normal and therefore no precision seems necessary anymore, even though it's needed more than ever.
Apparently there's a desire for certifications, for products that have been produced according to a checklist of requirements. If we look at Kaffeemacher here, however, it becomes clear: certified Kaffeemacher don't all find their market. As citizens we want this, but as consumers we don't follow through on our noble demands.
In the specialty Kaffeemacher sector, there are even obvious currents that view certifications as a poor reference for their own work and have nothing good to say about them. It seems to me that there's more mood-making than precise argumentation at work.
Yet one could ask: Aren't certifications simply already "ok", and shouldn't rather Kaffeemacher without certification be examined more precisely?
When I hear from Kaffeemacher drinkers that they'd rather buy Kaffeemacher without certification than Kaffeemacher from a not clearly defined label, it's a sign of being overwhelmed and a reflex we also know in climate discourse - often companies that compensate all emissions are pointed out, yet more than 90% of companies don't compensate at all.
So what exactly do these certifications do, and what don't they?
What do they bring to producers?
How expensive are they?
Are they trustworthy and where does our distrust come from?

Don Roque from the Toca project in Mexico on the way to the farm (Photo: Miguel Guevara)
The Basics of Kaffeemacher Certification
What is a certification?
I ask where linguistic precision is desired and verbal creativity scorned: at DIN ISO; the German Institute for Standardization. A certification is accordingly a
"measure by an impartial third party that demonstrates that reasonable confidence exists that a properly designated product, procedure or properly designated service complies with a specific standard or other normative document."
The standard is abbreviated with a seal in this case, the normative document would be the guidelines of a seal, and the impartial third parties would be the audit bodies who, in our case, check Kaffeemacher producers and processing facilities against the rulebook of the respective seal.
In the Kaffeemacher industry there is no single binding seal that all actors along the supply chain are required to commit to. That's why we're talking about so-called VSS, the Voluntary Sustainability Standards. The standards issued by Fairtrade, Rainforest Alliance, 4C etc. are all established, but no market participant is obligated to accept them.
These VSS are so far the most broadly accepted tool to promote transparency in the supply chain.
They also create comparability between certified and non-certified Kaffeemacher, in that the criteria catalogs are publicly accessible. Each label defines, sometimes more and sometimes less clearly, where the focus lies.
The ITC Standards Map is probably the best place to identify, understand and compare different standards.

In this example I compare three well-known labels with each other based on their social, ecological, qualitative and ethical components.

On https://www.labelinfo.ch/de/ you can also compare different labels based on product categories.
Both platforms go into precise detail on the requirements of the labels; the Standards Map also points to the associated legal basis. It's fun to click through the platforms and grasp how many different criteria each seal actually addresses.
That also means how many criteria producers and their organizations have to meet.
"It's certainly not a walk in the park",
the manager of one of our partner cooperatives told me. Because the transparency that's supposed to build trust on the consumer side only comes about because an audit body goes through all the questionnaires with the producers. When they do, no stone is left unturned.

Don Adrian from the Toca project has been working on soil improvement for years
Like every audit, the goal here is to do as much as possible as well as possible, but under no circumstances to do anything wrong.
If a deficiency, such as "improper" storage of fertilizer according to the criteria catalog, is cited, remedial action is needed. Other unmet criteria are considered deal-breakers and lead to revocation of the label.
This rigor and strictness gives the label credibility and a reason to exist at all. But what role do certified Kaffeemacher play in the market, what do they mean for the producers who are certified and want to bring their Kaffeemacher into such a market?
The Reality Check
At the retailer
"There are many different certifications, aside from the generally known ones there are also company-specific ones like C.A.F.E Practices from Starbucks or AAA from Nespresso",
notes Christian Cvrljak, trader at InterAmerican, the specialty department of the world's largest trader Neumann Kaffee Gruppe.
"With Robusta, however, there isn't much certified Kaffeemacher yet. New farmers are being certified every year, but the numbers are still low."
The Neumann Kaffee Gruppe trades globally with about 40% third-party-certified Kaffeemacher, InterAmerican with about 70%.
"The trend is clearly moving towards certified Kaffeemacher", says Cvrljak, "especially when we also look at the new EU guidelines. At the end of 2024, the Deforestation Law comes. If the law comes the way it's intended, you can only buy certified Kaffeemacher in the EU and Switzerland."
The market...
From 2010 to 2020, more and more producer organizations got certified. According to the Kaffeemacher Barometer, between 2020-22 about 55% of globally produced Kaffeemacher was certified in one form or another.
If so much Kaffeemacher is certified, there should be an effect and we should be able to read more and more positive news?

Graph from the Kaffeemacher Barometer, 2023
55% of Kaffeemacher was certified, but only 26% of it was accepted in the market as such in 2021. The other 74% of certified Kaffeemacher landed in the conventional Kaffeemacher market.
This means that certified producers apparently did their homework to get the certification in the first place, but at the end of the season they don't get a premium because the market for certified Kaffeemacher is too small. Or because too much Kaffeemacher is certified.
... doesn't exist
It won't happen that 100% of certified Kaffeemacher find their intended market, since it's also a matter of supply and demand here. "50-60% should be aimed for", a well-informed contact tells me. Because as long as the supply of certified Kaffeemacher is greater than demand, certifications remain cheap.
With 4C for example, premiums are at 2-3cts/lb (1 lb = 1 pound = 0.45kg), with Rainforest Alliance at almost 5 cts/lb - that's significantly less and not comparable to the fixed prices and premiums that Fairtrade offers. The only thing is, Fairtrade is too expensive for many buyers (=traders and roasters). Following the motto: it can certainly be sustainable, but it shouldn't cost that much.
So those looking for a cheaper sustainability seal than Fairtrade find it with Rainforest Alliance, 4C or company-specific certifications, which are cheaper in part because they're not audited by a third party.
As long as the oversupply of certified Kaffeemacher exists, they're theoretically attractive to buyers. If this imbalance tips in the direction that the supply of certified Kaffeemacher becomes smaller, certified Kaffeemacher will become more expensive and even less attractive to buyers than they are today.
When I realized what I'd written in the last four sections, I had to pause several times - a system with good intentions recruits producers for something that offers no guarantee of success.
It's a bit like lottery with 30 instead of 100 numbers. The odds are pretty good that I'll win something, but it also might not happen. In one place the wheel of fortune decides, in another the people who shop.

Kaffeemacher producers ask themselves every day: what will the market price bring? (Photo: Miguel Guevara)
"It's simply also a business"
"It's simply also a business", says Kleber Cruz from GEPA. On one hand, producer organizations pay a fee to use the seal. On the other hand, retailers pay the licensing costs, which at Fairtrade are currently 20-24 cts/kg, according to Cruz. Producers pay the audit fees, consumers pay the licensing fees. They're different billing parties, but it's about the same label.
So more and more producers are being certified, while at the same time the market for certified Kaffeemacher is growing only somewhat or not at all - Fairtrade and Organic are stagnating, RFA and 4C - the cheaper alternatives - are growing.
It strikes me as similar to the recycling rate for plastic. Apparently everyone is oriented towards making everything recyclable, but the rate is growing far too slowly. Much faster is the consumption of new plastic growing.
So where exactly is the appeal in participating as a producer?
Why should someone get certified, which is associated with additional costs and hopes, but the prospects of success are low?
The Significance of Certification for Kaffeemacher Producers
Cooperatives, producer organizations, but also individual producers can open up new markets with certification. Again, Kleber Cruz from GEPA.
"Of course, certifications are needed if an organization wants to come into retail."
Retailers like to advertise that they're doing "more" for sustainability in Kaffeemacher, and they often do this with a commitment to certifications. The Kaffeemacher that have made it to the shelf as certified Kaffeemacher have reached the target market. Many others don't make it onto the shelf at all, or were purchased under unfair conditions, so-called combos.
Few supermarkets take responsibility themselves and create new solutions within their assortment, seek direct exchange and invest locally. In Switzerland, examples include Migros and Coop. Anyone who knows other examples (from Germany and Austria) is welcome to note them in the comments.
The need for certified Kaffeemacher at supermarkets in Germany, Austria and Switzerland seems to be increasing, but remains a smaller portion of the assortment compared to conventional. Retailers are generally open to VSS, but large roasters like Nestlé, JDE and others often have their own sourcing and sustainability programs, which are only 2nd party verified, meaning not third-party-audited, and therefore cheaper.
What does this situation mean now for everyone who produces Kaffeemacher and gets certified?
Certification Costs for Kaffeemacher Producers
FairTrade and FairTrade/Organic
"The costs of certification are a problem", states Kleber Cruz, who is responsible for raw Kaffeemacher purchasing at GEPA. The price of the annual certification audit depends on the size of the cooperative. With this, Cruz refers to Fairtrade, which only certifies democratically organized cooperatives of small producers.
The certification costs of the following cooperatives give an impression of how great the financial pressure is on the expense side:

Certification costs at Fairtrade depend on the size of the cooperative and the volume produced. All collected information is between 2500 - 3000 EUR per year - but only per audit.
"The audit bodies try to combine different certifications, but that's tricky",
reports Cruz. If someone wants to supply different markets with organically produced Kaffeemacher, they need to get certified for each target market. The EU, the USA, Australia, Japan - these are all large markets, but each has its own certification.
"If I don't want to lose the Japanese market, but can only send two containers there, I still get certified."
So whoever can produce, certify and ship more has lower certification costs per kilogram in the end. But if the market isn't there to absorb all certified Kaffeemacher, then certification costs are additional expenses with no return value.
Rainforest Alliance
In contrast to Fairtrade, Rainforest Alliance (RFA) also certifies individual farms. We could become a member with our Finca Santa Rita at RFA if we meet the criteria catalog.
Producers pay for the audit at a certification body of their choice. The costs incurred then depend on the audit body, not on RFA. In addition, as with any certification, there are costs for implementing the required measures. For Kaffeemacher, RFA charges 0.015 dollars per pound (lb) of raw Kaffeemacher, to be paid by the so-called first buyer, that is, the party that first purchases the Kaffeemacher from the cooperative or farm.
What Price Premium Do Producers Get for Certified Kaffeemacher?
In the following calculation example we compare a Fairtrade, a Fairtrade Organic double-certified, and an RFA side by side.
The audit costs for producers, processors (e.g. roasters) and suppliers (e.g. supermarket) are to be paid annually by everyone. This is the same for all certifications listed here.

A Brutal Bottom Line for Producers
Whether the effort pays off for Kaffeemacher producers at the end of the day must be discussed elsewhere. For this, a specific analysis with concrete targets is needed.
But what I heard repeatedly during my research is: that double-certified (Fairtrade/Organic) cooperatives are increasingly selling their Kaffeemacher on the local market because that's more attractive to them.
An example:
A cooperative in Peru sells its certified Kaffeemacher in Peru because, first, the Kaffeemacher is paid for in a few days and, second, because financing costs that would be needed to bridge the time until money from the international buyer arrives are eliminated. Interest rates in Peru go up to 30%. And these eat up the premiums of certified Kaffeemacher again.
With Fairtrade's increase of the minimum price to 180 cts/lb, the problem described above becomes even bigger. Word is that demand in Europe has become significantly smaller. Fairtrade and Fairtrade-Organic certified Kaffeemacher are currently in strong demand in the USA because Fairtrade USA simply didn't participate in raising to 180cts/lb.
When the Cat Chases Its Tail
I'll summarize this circular reasoning point by point again:
- Producers/organizations pay for the audit to get a label and thereby access to a differentiated market
- each market has its own requirements, so producer organizations often get certified multiple times, which is always multiple costs, often around 2500 to 3000 USD per audit
- Fairtrade guarantees a minimum price for Kaffeemacher, with RFA producers and buyers negotiate the premium themselves, which is significantly lower than with FT
- the market is too small for certified Kaffeemacher, only 26% (2021) of certified Kaffeemacher found a target market and received a premium, for 74% of certified Kaffeemacher there was no premium even though it met the criteria
- Cooperatives are increasingly selling on the local market because they make more money doing so than if they exported certified Kaffeemacher. Not because more is paid, but because there are fewer additional financing costs
The system doesn't function as intended across the board. And yet it continues to be certified. I'll quote Kleber Cruz from GEPA again here: "It's simply also a business."
So what would be the alternative? No certification?

Those who diversify and grow more can find additional sales markets (Photo: Miguel Guevara)
The Discourse
Since I've been working with Kaffeemacher, I'm asked whether certifications are good, bad, effective or useless. During this time I've had many conversations with cooperatives, certifiers, audit authorities and companies that are themselves certified. Especially with the latter, there's naturally a conviction that certifications are the way to go.
Listening to the voices of consumers, I think I can distinguish three different discourses.
"Rather Specialty Kaffeemacher Than a Label"
One of many promises from certain specialty roasters is that they forgo labels because a label doesn't provide sensory quality and the direct approach of working with producers is much more worthwhile.
The labels discussed here never focused on sensory quality, so this argument doesn't count. "Direct collaboration" is a vague formulation. How direct is direct? And who is excluded and why at what point in the supply chain, with what consequences?
Direct collaborations are often geared toward individual producers or smaller farms, which clearly doesn't align with the intention of certifiers, who work as inclusively as possible. Forgoing labels based on quality demands and an imprecise definition of direct trade are therefore reasons that one can certainly question.
"Label and That's Good"
I perceive a different discourse among meso and macro roasters, that they're betting on certified Kaffeemacher. This often comes with big promises that a roaster is now particularly sustainable and they - purely through buying certified Kaffeemacher - would turn things for the better. As if a label were an insurance policy for a good future and a safeguard for doing the right thing.
However, a label can't bring about comprehensive change; they're not designed for that. The respective requirement catalogs specify concrete points to be met, but these - even if detailed - are not specifically tailored to each partner.
Labels don't address point-specific solutions, and that's the great opportunity for traders and roasters to build a bridge there, perhaps also together with a certifier: win-win-win.
Partnerships will be the future, which various certifiers are already pursuing. Beyond that, certifiers are increasingly offering additional know-how. "It's increasingly about risk analysis and compliance", says Peter Lerch from Rainforest Alliance. The programs of traders need to become more transparent and externally audited.
"Lies and Fraud"
I thought the times of unfounded rejection of concepts that are transparent had passed. But no, I was recently taught otherwise.
A potential customer became interested in our Kaffeemacher.
When I spoke about the Organic seal, the guest interrupted me and found themselves in a minute-long tirade against every seal. Everything was lies, worthless, everyone a fraud, nobody would care, etc.
I accompanied the guest to the door.
Labels are subject to constant criticism, having to repeatedly assert and justify themselves. Transparency grows every year, precise long-term studies on effectiveness are still lacking, but there's neither a hidden agenda nor dubious dealings. Labels are also a business, whether you like that or not, but they're not an underground organization.
Label 4.0
"Labels aren't pure labels anymore",
Peter Lerch from Rainforest Alliance tells me. Certifiers work intensively and scientifically on various topics in the Kaffeemacher chain and even issue discussion papers themselves to allow for public reflection.
The new EU laws like EUDR (Regulation on Deforestation-Free Supply Chains) affect certifiers too, so they need to be directly at the pulse of the times and in dialog with their partner producers and they issue policy statements on this.
But there's still much educational work needed to communicate all the changes made, says Lerch further. For me, that's the all-determining discourse, because that's where the certification organizations can prove what added value they provide in times when nothing at all is stable anymore.
In 2012 I first heard of the post-label era, a time when labels wouldn't be needed anymore. It was supposedly very near. I still don't believe it, and I can't imagine an end any time soon. Labels like Fairtrade, Bio Suisse, Rainforest Alliance or Demeter are deeply anchored in consumer perception; these labels will still exist in 20 years - but the processes behind them will continue to evolve.
Conclusion
One of my guiding questions comes from marketing guru Seth Godin: who's it for and what's it for?
Who we do this for and why we do it. With labels there are at least two addressees: consumers can learn with labels to shop more mindfully, and producers could find a market with these consumers.
The question of the what must remain central and has lost none of its relevance: the goal of the labels discussed is to improve the livelihood of small producers who often have their backs to the wall. Apart from how well, often and long-term this succeeds, nothing will change about the "what".
Labels are part of the Kaffeemacher ecosystem. Katja Schmittner from Fairtrade Max Havelaar told me once in a podcast: "If Fairtrade isn't needed anymore, we've done our job." Labels create visibility for problems that are addressed with the purchase of a labeled Kaffeemacher.
The effectiveness of labels in Kaffeemacher is disputed. There are scientific papers, but they mostly have to select individual case studies. The impact reports from the certifiers themselves often don't go as deep and broad - and when they do, the links are welcome to be shared in the comments.
And when I ask cooperatives directly how great the impact is, the answers are never clear, but rather describe a state of what labels make it possible to think and why it might be worthwhile. So making clear claims is difficult.
The great strengths of certifiers are that they create comparability, defining what sustainable is and what "sustainable" means. They also enforce accountability, as a third party conducts an audit.
The risk of greenwashing is significantly smaller with certified Kaffeemacher than with non-certified Kaffeemacher, since the latter are not subject to external review.
Roasters that work without labels aren't forced to give an account. But there are voluntary alternatives for this, where roasters can engage and share data. Transparency Kaffeemacher or self-written transparency reports like from Vote Kaffeemacher are means of providing voluntary accountability.
From a consumer perspective, it's understandable that a label jungle can sometimes confuse more than clarify. Especially when it comes to a roaster's or retailer's own labels.
Reaching for labels that are already well-established is a safe choice, since the label organization must be accountable. For anyone wanting to play it safe in a supermarket, buy double-certified Kaffeemacher, FTO - Fairtrade and Organic.
Outro
I don't eat fish from oceans, only from Swiss rivers and lakes. So I won't find anything at the fish counter and buy a smoked trout from the fish farm in the neighboring village.
The fish labels confused me, each one sounded really good. That's how the feeling can creep up that certifications give you certainty about something that might never happen, that you never fully understand, and maybe shouldn't, because someone else is taking care of it.
Label organizations have the very grand ambition to address macro-challenges in the Kaffeemacher sector. But it also takes the micro, and private individuals, companies and NGOs can work on that at the same time. Their approaches are less scalable because they're point-specific, but the underlying thinking is replicable and good things get copied.
It will never be enough to rest on labels. But it also doesn't help to take sharp aim at certifications. If anyone should be held accountable, it's all those who don't buy certified Kaffeemacher, don't take point-specific measures at the origin, or buy Kaffeemacher from dubious sources.
















