Four methods, one goal: the caffeine must come out of the bean, everything else should stay in. How well this succeeds determines the taste, the price, and whether measurable solvent residues end up in the cup. We spoke with decaffeinator CR3 in Bremen, looked up patents and limits, and found an error that appears in almost every article on the topic.

Decaffeination always happens to green coffee, never to roasted coffee. Four extraction agents are in use: dichloromethane, ethyl acetate, water, and CO₂. The difference between them lies in selectivity, not in marketing name. And decaffeinated does not mean caffeine-free: a decaffeinated espresso contains 3 to 15.8 milligrams of caffeine.
What all methods have in common during production
Decaffeination always happens to green coffee, the bean before roasting. There is no industrial process that decaffeinates roasted coffee.
Meike Holtmann works at ANKA, the research and innovation subsidiary of CR3, on these exact processes. She describes four steps that are the same for all methods:
The difference between methods lies in the second step, specifically in three factors: temperature, pressure, and time. Holtmann calls it "the operating mode of the entire process".
Selectivity means: how specifically does an extraction agent target caffeine and leave everything else alone. A less selective agent also pulls out fats, acids, and aromatic compounds. This is the real reason why some decafs taste flat.
Dichloromethane: nine hours and the best price-to-performance ratio
Dichloromethane, or DCM or methylene chloride, is the most common method worldwide. The reason is simple: it works better than anything else. Holtmann calls DCM "the most efficient extraction agent for caffeine".
Pressure, temperature, and target value from the original Procter & Gamble patent from 1971. The beans are pre-moistened to 41 to 50 weight percent water, the solvent-to-bean ratio is 3:1 to 5:1.
Short process time means low energy consumption, and that directly affects the price. Holtmann: "The price-to-performance ratio is right."
What many are surprised to learn: DCM is not the most aggressive, but rather a gentler agent.
"It is relatively selective for caffeine too. Not so many co-extracts come out with it."
If you start with good green coffee quality, you retain a lot of aroma. But we haven't tasted a specialty coffee from the DCM method yet. That probably has something to do with the fact that it's a chemical process and market acceptance is limited.
In the indirect DCM method, the solvent never touches the bean. The coffee is soaked in hot water, the caffeine goes into the water, and only this water is treated with DCM. Then the aromatic compounds return to the bean with the water. We found no documented numbers for temperatures and times of this variant.
How much dichloromethane remains in the coffee? 34 products tested
A research group measured 34 commercially available decaffeinated roasted coffees from EU trade in 2024, using headspace-GC-MS. The results:
| Measurement | Value |
|---|---|
| Range in roasted coffee | 5.7 to 816.6 µg/kg |
| Mean value | 127 µg/kg (0.127 mg/kg) |
| Median | 59.5 µg/kg (0.060 mg/kg) |
| Legal maximum EU | 2 mg/kg (2,000 µg/kg) |
| Legal maximum USA | 10 mg/kg (10 ppm) |
| Transfer into beverage, filter coffee | Median 26.8 percent |
| Transfer into beverage, French press | Median 43.1 percent |
Fabian, Süße-Herrmann, McGaffin & Hielscher (2024), Proceedings 109(1), 33. Limits: EU Directive 2009/32/EG Annex Part II, 21 CFR 173.255.
Three things are clear. First: DCM is detectable in finished coffee, the statement "nothing is left after roasting" is too sweeping. Second: the highest measured individual value is about 41 percent of the limit, the median about three percent. Third: a quarter to just over two-fifths of the residue ends up in the cup, and the French press transfers significantly more than the paper filter.
Holtmann says about the residues: "The required maximum amounts are undercut by a factor of one hundred." The median of the study is about a factor of 34, the mean about 16. That fits in that order of magnitude, though individual values vary considerably.

Pure caffeine at Descamex, Córdoba, Mexico
Why the topic is in focus right now, once again
The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) has classified dichloromethane since 2017 in Group 2A, as "probably carcinogenic to humans". In the USA, since November 2023, there has been an application from several environmental and health organizations to remove methylene chloride from food approval. The FDA reopened the comment period on May 28, 2026, and closed it on June 29, 2026; a decision has not yet been made. We found no comparable initiative in the EU.
Ethyl acetate, the sugarcane process
Ethyl acetate goes by two names. The technical one is ethyl acetate, the nicer one is Sugarcane Process. Both refer to the same molecule.
"Industrially, it is used in synthetic form. But it is also present in traces naturally in sugarcane, in sugar beets, or even in fruit, and can also be produced from natural components. And that's why it also carries this name Sugarcane Processing."
Technically, ethyl acetate behaves similarly to DCM, with one difference: "It is not quite as selective for caffeine as dichloromethane. So the process times are slightly longer." At Descafecol in Manizales, the decaffeination plant in Colombia, the solvent cycles run for about eight hours according to the process diagram, after thirty minutes of steaming.
Cycles and steaming time from the Descafecol process diagram, Manizales. The residue specification of 20 ppm is a voluntary statement by Descafecol; Cafe Imports cites a maximum of 10 ppm in their process diagram.
The legal situation is the real difference. Unlike dichloromethane, there is no numerical EU limit for ethyl acetate. It appears in Part I of the Annex to Directive 2009/32/EG, among the solvents permitted for all purposes under good manufacturing practice.
The most interesting set of numbers for this method comes from a 1999 review and shows what decaffeination costs:
| Condition | Duration | Caffeine removed | Loss of soluble solids |
|---|---|---|---|
| Room temperature, 27 degrees | 8 h | 37 to 39 % | 9 to 10 % |
| Room temperature, 27 degrees | 14 h | 42 to 44 % | 14 to 15 % |
| With hot water circulation | 8 h | 62 to 64 % | 34 to 36 % |
| With hot water circulation | 16 h | 78 to 80 % | 40 to 42 % |
Ramalakshmi & Raghavan (1999), Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition 39(5), Table 5. Laboratory conditions, not industrial parameters.
Water methods: why water alone doesn't work
The most obvious idea is also the wrong one. If you put coffee beans in hot water, caffeine dissolves, but so does everything else. You end up with a cup of coffee and a flavorless bean.
Water methods solve this with a trick. Holtmann: "The coffee bean is extracted with hot water or with hot caffeine-free green coffee extract." This extract is saturated with all soluble coffee components, just without caffeine. So essentially only caffeine can migrate out of the bean, everything else stays in because the solution is already full.
The caffeine-laden extract then runs through adsorber filters. "A caffeine-free but aroma-rich extract comes back out of these adsorber filters." The cycle starts again.
"We found that the filters we use also have a lower affinity for co-extracts, which has a very positive effect on the aroma of the decaffeinated coffee, because we have fewer losses."
Two suppliers carry water methods in their names. Swiss Water in Delta, British Columbia, works with green coffee extract and charcoal filters. Descamex in Córdoba, Veracruz, calls its method Mountain Water Process.
Values from a 1980 patent for the water method with adsorption. Swiss Water and Descamex do not publish their own process data.
"99.9% caffeine-free", well, sort of
Neither Swiss Water nor Descamex publish temperatures, pressures, process times, or a decaffeination rate. The common claim "99.9 percent caffeine-free" for the Swiss Water Process could not be traced to a primary source; it comes from a teaching document that itself refers to a blog. So we don't report it as fact.
The coffee with which everything started here comes from such a method. Our Sueño from Mexico is decaffeinated at Descamex with water, the coffee comes from Rancho San Felipe.

Supercritical CO₂: from 31 degrees and 73.8 bar
Carbon dioxide is known as a gas and as dry ice. Above about 31 degrees and 73.8 bar, it becomes something else: supercritical. It then has the density of a liquid and the diffusion behavior of a gas, and in this state it dissolves caffeine.
Kurt Zosel invented this in Oberhausen; the patent was filed on February 5, 1970. It specifies 40 to 80 degrees, 120 to 180 atmospheres, a water content of 15 to 30 percent in the beans, 5 to 15 hours of decaffeination, and residual caffeine below 0.01 percent. The core of the patent is a subtlety: it's the moisture that makes supercritical CO₂ a medium that can pick up caffeine.
At today's industrial scale, the values are higher. Holtmann mentions "extremely high pressures of 250 to 300 bar and high temperatures of 60 to 80 degrees". A 2017 life cycle assessment study documents a facility with 250 bar and 90 degrees, five hours of steaming, then 11.5 hours of extraction for Arabica and 22 hours for Robusta, with 97 percent caffeine removal.
Globally, according to the Max Planck Society, about 100,000 tons of green coffee per year are processed using the supercritical method. That's roughly one percent of the global harvest.
Subcritical CO₂: liquid at 70 bar, seven days process time
If you lower the pressure and temperature below the critical point, you get liquid CO₂. It's slower and more expensive, and that's exactly why it's interesting, especially sensorially.
CR3 calls this method Carbonic Natural. Holtmann describes it like this: "The CO₂ is in a liquid state and flows through the pretreated beans and is incredibly selective." After extraction, it depressurizes, the pressure drops from 70 bar to ambient, and the caffeine precipitates out of the CO₂. It is captured in a water stream, and the caffeine-free CO₂ goes back into the next batch.
Pressure, temperature, and residual caffeine from a documented factory visit by Belco. 97 to 99 percent of the caffeine exits in the liquid CO₂ phase there.
Sebastian Gabriel, Marketing and Sales at CR3, explained it to us like this once: CO₂ is "a lazy solvent".
Two points that matter in everyday life. The CO₂ comes from natural carbonation, so the method is organic-certifiable. And: our Apas Decaf from Brazil is decaffeinated this way, as is our Dipilto Decaf from Nicaragua.

The triglyceride method: much claimed, little proven
Many articles mention a fifth method: the beans bathe in hot coffee oil, the triglycerides in the oil pull the caffeine out.
We found no primary source for this. No patent, no peer-reviewed study, no manufacturer information provides temperature, duration, oil-to-bean ratio, or decaffeination rate. We examined and ruled out three relevant patents regularly cited in the literature for this method, and they actually describe other processes.
The four methods in direct comparison
CO₂ appears twice in the table because it runs in two operating modes. The extraction agent remains the same.
| Method | Extraction agent | Duration | Pressure / Temperature | Selectivity | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dichloromethane (DCM) | Dichloromethane | approx. 9 h | 2–14 bar / 60–99 °C | high | low |
| Ethyl acetate (Sugarcane) | Ethyl acetate | approx. 8 h cycles | not published | medium | low to medium |
| Water (Swiss Water, Mountain Water) | Green coffee extract plus adsorber filter | not published | 50–100 °C (1980 patent) | high, filter-dependent | high |
| CO₂, supercritical | Supercritical CO₂ | 11.5–22 h | 250–300 bar / 60–90 °C | high | high |
| CO₂, subcritical (Carbonic Natural) | Liquid CO₂ | 6–7 days | 70–80 bar / 23 °C | very high | high |
"Not published" means: the value is not published by any manufacturer or in any primary source.
What "decaffeinated" legally means, and why "EU limit 0.1 percent" is wrong
Precision matters: statements like "in the EU, decaffeinated coffee may contain up to 0.1 percent caffeine" appear on every other page on the topic. They are not quite right as stated.
The EU regulates exclusively coffee extracts with Directive 1999/4/EG, meaning soluble coffee. There the limit is 0.3 percent anhydrous caffeine relative to dry matter. For roasted coffee, we found no harmonized EU numerical value.
The 0.1 percent comes from national law:
| Legal area | Roasted coffee | Soluble coffee | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Germany | max. 1 g caffeine per kg coffee dry matter, i.e., 0.1 % | max. 3 g/kg, i.e., 0.3 % | Coffee Ordinance, § 2 Subsection 3 |
| Switzerland | max. 0.1 weight percent, based on dry matter | max. 0.3 weight percent | EDI Ordinance on Beverages |
| EU | no harmonized value found | 0.3 % | Directive 1999/4/EG |
Practically, nothing changes for you as a drinker: the same value of 0.1 percent applies in Germany and Switzerland.
What actually ends up in your cup
The limit says nothing about how much caffeine you actually drink. For that, you need measurements of the beverage itself.
The reference study for this is from 2006. Ten filter coffee decafs from nine chains and local cafés ranged from 8.6 to 13.9 mg caffeine per 473 ml. Decaffeinated espresso came in at 3 to 15.8 mg per shot.
To put this in perspective: green coffee contains about one percent caffeine for Arabica and about two percent for Canephora, depending on the variety. A 2020 study cites ranges of 0.8 to 1.4 percent for Arabica and 1.7 to 4.0 percent for Robusta. Roasting changes this hardly at all, because caffeine is heat-stable.
What this residual caffeine does in your body is a separate question. How long caffeine lasts, how quickly it breaks down, and when it starts to disturb your sleep, we've written about separately.
Bremen as the caffeine capital
"Decaffeination was invented in Bremen. Many people don't know that. And you could say Bremen is still the world capital of decaffeination."
Both are true, with a clarification. The patent "Preparation of coffee" was filed on May 4, 1906, and issued on September 1, 1908. It bears three names: Johann Friedrich Meyer Jr., Ludwig Roselius, and Karl Heinrich Wimmer. Roselius is almost always cited as the sole inventor, but he is not.
And the solvent was indeed benzene, literally in the patent: "We have found that benzene (also called benzol) is eminently suitable for this purpose." Kaffee HAG was founded in the same year, 1906. The widespread anecdote that a coffee shipment damaged by seawater gave Roselius the idea sounds dramatic, but perhaps a bit too dramatic. I haven't found a reliable source for it yet.
As for the world capital: in Bremen, Coffein Compagnie processes around 120,000 tons of green coffee per year in five facilities and calls itself the global market leader. Additionally, CR3 is also based in Bremen. There is no independent global capacity ranking because Descamex, Descafecol, Demus, and Swiss Water do not publish their capacities.
Which method makes the best coffee?
Stacey Linden from Swiss Water said something like this to me in conversation for the main article:
The decaffeination process leaves a sensory footprint, more or less depending on the method. What we find interesting is the question of whether this sensory change is a flaw or whether it can add a new quality.
Quick and cheap methods like DCM leave what we perceive as a soy-like character. Water methods can leave a malty note in flatter coffees. Ethyl acetate can increase acidity, while the subcritical CO₂ method can mellow the coffee somewhat.
If you know that as an importer or roaster, then you look for the right green coffee for the right method, and that's how a new, sensorially interesting product can emerge.
Decaffeination as quality improvement of poor green coffee?
We asked Meike Holtmann whether it's true that in the past, mainly poor quality was decaffeinated. Her answer: "I don't experience that here on our company grounds today. A large portion of the coffees we sell here as raw material have good, sometimes even very good sensory quality." The low qualities, affectionately called "bird feed or muesli coffees" in-house, are extremely rare.
What's interesting is her observation about the effect: "With off-flavor qualities, you sometimes actually perceive it as an upgrade of the coffee." Less so with good qualities. So the process smooths things out—it helps poor green coffee and costs good green coffee something.
To judge decaf, you need to know both: the green coffee quality and the method used. More on taste, faster aging, and why decaf extracts differently is in the main article on decaffeinated coffee.
To listen to
Conclusion
Four methods, and none is universally the best. Dichloromethane is fast, cheap, and more selective than its reputation suggests, but leaves measurable residues and stands under regulatory scrutiny. Ethyl acetate is similarly quick, somewhat less selective, and legally more loosely regulated. Water methods avoid solvents entirely, but publish hardly any process data. CO₂, in its subcritical operating mode, is the slowest and most expensive method and, according to CR3, the most selective.
You'll find our decaffeinated coffees in the decaf collection, each with the method specified.
Sources
Conversations
Meike Holtmann, Research and Innovation, ANKA (Research and Innovation subsidiary of CR3), Bremen.
Sebastian Gabriel, Marketing and Sales, CR3 Coffee Refinement, Bremen.
Stacey Linden, Swiss Water, Delta, British Columbia.
Studies and Reviews
Fabian, Süße-Herrmann, McGaffin & Hielscher (2024): Dichloromethane Residues in Decaffeinated Roasted Coffees, Proceedings 109(1), 33.
Ramalakshmi & Raghavan (1999): Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition 39(5), Table 5.
McCusker, Fuehrlein, Goldberger, Gold & Cone (2006): Caffeine Content of Decaffeinated Coffee, Journal of Analytical Toxicology 30(8), 611–613.
Gaibor, Morales & Carrillo (2020): Determination of Caffeine Content in Robusta Roasted Coffee (Coffea canephora) by RP-UHPLC-PDA, Asian Journal of Crop Science 12(2), 90–96.
De Marco, Riemma & Iannone (2017): Supercritical Carbon Dioxide Decaffeination Process, a Life Cycle Assessment Study, Chemical Engineering Transactions 57, 1699–1704.
Patents
Meyer Jr., Roselius & Wimmer: "Preparation of coffee", filed May 4, 1906, issued September 1, 1908.
Zosel: Process for Decaffeination with Supercritical CO₂, filed February 5, 1970.
Procter & Gamble: Decaffeination with Dichloromethane, 1971.
Water method with adsorption, 1980.
Law
Coffee Ordinance, § 2 Subsection 3 (Germany).
Directive 2009/32/EG on Extraction Solvents, Annex Part I and Part II.
Directive 1999/4/EG on Coffee Extracts.
EDI Ordinance on Beverages (Switzerland).
Ordinance on Technical Provisions for Foodstuffs, VTVV, Annex 1 (Switzerland).
21 CFR 173.255 (USA).
Further Information
IARC Monographs: Classification of dichloromethane in Group 2A, 2017.
FDA, Proceeding for Removal of Methylene Chloride from Food Approval, ongoing since November 2023.
Max Planck Society, information on the supercritical CO₂ method.
Process diagrams Descafecol (Manizales) and Cafe Imports.
Documented factory visit by Belco at CR3.
Coffein Compagnie, Bremen, own statements on processing volume.
















