Home / Coffee knowledge / Environmental impact of coffee cultivation
    Nachhaltigkeit
    Umweltauswirkung von Kaffeeanbau

    Environmental impact of coffee cultivation

    Tobias Milz koordiniert den Nachhaltigkeits-Bereich der Kaffeemacher:innen. Er sammelt und erarbeitet Wissen, mit dem wir selbst mehr über den Fußabdruck des Kaffees entlang der Kaffeekette lernen. Das ermöglicht, dass wir selbst besser werden. Gleichzeitig stellen wir alles was wir lernen dem Markt zur Verfügung, um eine sozial-ökologische Transformation der Kaffeebranche voran zu treiben. Tobias ist aber auch ein Allrounder: als gelernte Koch ist er auch an der Sensorik-Front unseres Unternehmens aktiv und als Programmierer schmiert er unsere Schnittstellen. Ein bunter Fähigkeiten-Mix, angetrieben durch Neugier und eine ordentliche Portion Kaffee-Begeisterung.

    Environmental impact analysis using the example of Finca Santa Rita in Nicaragua with the help of the Cool Farm Tool.

    Download study: Environmental impact of coffee cultivation Kaffeemacher

    Note

    In this article/study, we calculate the carbon footprint of coffee using the example of our coffee farm Santa Rita from cultivation to roasting. Santa Rita is located in the Dipilto region in northern Nicaragua and is a small farm of 4.16 ha. The figures are based on the 2021/22 harvest and, with relatively low yields, represent only a snapshot in time. At the time of data collection, the farm was undergoing major renovation in many areas, so the harvest volume was low and thus the carbon footprint per kilogram was high. However, the study also demonstrates a framework with which further coffee farms and the footprint along the coffee chain can be calculated.

    The study summarizes essential aspects of our work in the research and work area of sustainability at Kaffeemacher. This area is led by environmental engineer Tobias Milz.

    Abstract

    The CO₂ balance for the 2021/2022 harvest was determined using the Cool Farm Tool. This is a 4.16 hectare farm in Dipilto, Nicaragua, operated by the Kaffeemacher, in partnership with Bridazul. The calculation is based on a yield of 268.26 kilograms of export-grade green coffee. The coffee farm was taken over by Kaffeemacher GmbH in 2017 and has been undergoing renovation ever since. During the period under review, fewer than half of the plants were in production (3665 in production; 5363 not in production). Fertilizer and plant protection products were applied across the entire farm, not just on productive areas. We therefore expect a reduced footprint per kilogram in the coming years. This will be achieved through improvements in practice as well as through increased yield as more trees come into production.

    The practice at Santa Rita is that on the farm, except for harvesting and the first cleaning of the coffee cherries, no further processing steps are carried out. The harvested cherries are transported to the partner farm "El Arbol", which is located 7.4 kilometers away, where they are further processed. The next steps then take place at the Dry Mill of Bridazul in Dipilto, which is a further 23.3 kilometers away. The green coffee is shipped together with other coffees from the Dipilto region and reaches our roastery in Basel, where it is roasted and packaged.

    The export-ready green coffee has a carbon footprint of 1.57 kilograms of CO₂ equivalent per kilogram, which corresponds to 101.15 kilograms of CO₂ equivalent per hectare and a total of 430.79 kilograms of CO₂ equivalent for the entire harvest.

    We deliberately decided not to include the existing trees and unused areas of the farm as a carbon sink in the calculation. We cannot guarantee that the trees will remain standing for the next 50 to 100 years in the event of forest fires or the sale of the farm. If we were to include these, approximately 1000 kg of CO₂ could be credited to the farm.

    Verteilung der Emissionen Santa Rita Roestkaffee

    Distribution of emissions from roasted coffee from Santa Rita

    Overall, our calculation of transport and the carbon footprint of the Kaffeemacher roastery in Basel in 2022 results in a CO₂ equivalent of 2.96 kilograms of CO₂ equivalent per kilogram of roasted coffee, assuming a roasting loss of 15 percent. The distribution of this footprint is as follows: The majority, namely just under 1.85 kilograms of CO₂ equivalent per kilogram, is attributable to roasted coffee, which corresponds to approximately 62.5 percent. The transport share is 22.5 percent, which corresponds to 0.66 kilograms of CO₂ equivalent per kilogram of roasted coffee. The roastery causes an additional 0.45 kilograms of CO₂ equivalent per kilogram, which is approximately 15 percent. The share of coffee from our own farm processed in the roastery is approximately 2 percent

    Introduction

    The study is an environmental impact assessment of the Santa Rita farm of Kaffeemacher. It was created with the help of the Cool Farm Tool.

    Farm

    The farm is Santa Rita with the associated area Mil Varidades, which has been owned by Kaffeemacher GmbH since 2017. The farm is located in northern Nicaragua, in the department of Nueva Segovia in the municipality of Dipilto. The farm covers 4.16 ha and at the time of data collection had 9028 coffee plants, of which 3665 are in production. The farm has been undergoing renovation since it was taken over by Kaffeemacher GmbH. Many plants were removed and new varieties were planted. As a rule, plants produce their first cherries after three years. This explains why only part of the plants are bearing fruit.

    The cultivation method is agroforestry cultivation with manual harvesting. So far, plant protection has been necessary to protect against Broca infestation or Roya, and synthetic fertilizer and plant protection products have been used to promote plant growth. The goal is to gradually eliminate these. To this end, they are to be replaced with "Biologicals" and self-produced compost. Next, Bridazul and Kaffeemacher are working together to centrally and efficiently produce high-quality compost from coffee production by-products.

    The farm is located 7.4 km away from El Arbol, another farm operated by Bridazul. Bridazul are the partners of Kaffeemacher who operate the farm on site. Except for an initial selection of cherries, all significant post-harvest processes do not take place on Finca Santa Rita, but on El Arbol.

    For further fermentation and drying of the cherries, the coffee is transported to Ocotal to Bridazul's Dry Mill, which is located 23.3 km away. This is also where the offices and laboratory are located. Before the coffee is exported, it is hulled at Edman Café in the same location and packaged in 30 kg jute bags with liners.


    Die Struktur vor Ort

    Santa Rita Stationen Map

    Limitations of the Analysis

    As a rule, environmental impact assessments only consider work on the farm. Since the farm would not function without partners, work outside the farm must also be included. Therefore, various factors such as energy consumption in the office and during processing must be proportionally allocated to the farm's coffees.

    The Cool Farm Tool does not account for waste or packaging materials. This means that jute bags, liners and other packaging used either for the coffee or in its production are not considered.

    The different resource situation in different countries also does not factor into the calculation. Therefore, the calculation of energy consumption is based solely on a global average with regard to electricity use.

    Data Uncertainties

    A major criticism of Environmental Impact Analyses (EIAs) is that communication often does not pay sufficient attention to uncertainties<1>. However, every environmental analysis must deal with uncertainties and assumptions. It is therefore very important to disclose these. In the following, you will find the uncertainties evaluated and contextualized by category.

    We have rated the uncertainties according to the German school grading system. From 1 very low uncertainty to 6 no certainty.

    Area Rating Comment
    Fertilizer
    2

    We know the exact quantities and types of fertilizer used

    Uncertainties lie in the composition information we found online and in the calculation.

    In our case, we have included all fertilizer, including applications to plants that do not yet produce a yield.

    Plant protection
    3

    We know the exact quantities and types of plant protection products used

    Uncertainties lie in the composition information we found online and in the calculation.

    In our case, we have included all fertilizer, including applications to plants that do not yet produce a yield.

    Harvest
    1 We know the exact amount of green coffee and roasted coffee.
    Waste management 2

    Relatively accurate estimate of the mass of Casulla.

    Casulla as what remains after the first grinding. It contains more fruit pulp than the Cascara.

    Cascara is the skin that remains after depulping.

    Transport
    1 Distances and work effort as well as vehicles are known
    Energy requirement
    2 Based on the invoices, it is clear to see how consumption is composed. Uncertainty regarding distribution and electricity mix
    Soil properties
    4 Soil studies are not quite up to date (2019)
    Processing
    2 Good basis. However, the allocation is an average value across all Santa Rita coffees.
    Wastewater
    3 Expert estimate

    Data Collection

    Most data was collected on site in April 2022. Using a questionnaire specifically developed for coffee farms and comprising over 200 questions, all ecological, economic and social factors were collected. Additional details for the calculation were provided by Bridazul. Bridazul bills the Kaffeemacher for all work, including materials used on Santa Rita. This allows us to track very precisely what, how much and when was used.

    Furthermore, Kaffeemacher are the only buyers of coffee from the farm, so we can determine exactly which processing was applied to which coffee. For the calculation, however, we must assume an average that affects water and energy consumption.

    Results

    The calculation shows that the total footprint of the 21/22 harvest is 420.78 kg CO₂ equivalents. This corresponds to 101.15 kg CO2e per hectare and 1.57 kg CO2e per kilogram of green coffee.


    CO2 N20 CH4 CO2e CO2e per ha CO2e per kg

    Wastewater

    0 0 0.22 6.03 1.45 0.02

    Waste management

    0 0.04 0.37 20.71 4.98 0.08
    Fertilizer production
    57.03 0 0 57.03 13.71 0.21
    Soil / Fertilizer
    0 0.21 0 57.12 13.73 0.21

    Plant protection

    36.30 0 0 36.30 8.73 0.14

    Energy consumed (Processing)

    139.50 0 0 139.50 33.53 0.52

    Energy consumption (Field)

    41.80 0 0 41.80 10.05 0.16

    Transport outside the operation

    62.29 0 0 62.29 14.97 0.23

    TOTAL




    420.78 101.15 1.57
    Santra Rita Ernte 21 22 Emissionen in CO2 aeq

    Energy Use (Electricity)

    At 33.2 percent, energy emissions for processing is the largest factor. This is due to the fact that these are heavily processed coffees.

    The coffees go through a controlled fermentation process at Bridazul, which also provides a cold storage facility to ensure a controlled environment. This results in high energy expenditure, even though the process only runs for one month of the year. If we assume electricity costs of $0.05 per pound of green coffee, this corresponds to a consumption of 126.56 kWh for our coffees.

    Fertilizer

    On many farms where plants are exposed to full sun, fertilizers make up a large part of emissions (> 80%). This becomes apparent when looking at the basis of the assumptions in studies used, for example in Ecoinvent. Ecoinvent is a widely used environmental database. However, Ecoinvent has no data set for coffee from Nicaragua, but does have one for Honduras. Due to the farm's proximity to Honduras, this data set can be used. Here, an application of NPK fertilizers of 343-223-221 kg/ha is assumed, resulting in emissions of 10.11 kg CO2e / kg green coffee.

    At Santa Rita, NPK fertilizer is applied at 6.56-5.80-26.67. Organic fertilizers are included here, as well as fertilizers for plants that are still growing and not yet producing a yield.

    The high fertilizer application in the Honduras data set achieves a yield of 1340 kg / ha. The yield at Santa Rita is 101.15 kg/ha in comparison. Thus, the yield is 13.25 times higher. However, the factor for nitrogen (N) fertilizer application is increased by a factor of 52.29, phosphorus by a factor of 38.45, and only for potassium is the factor smaller than the yield factor (8.29). However, it is expected that yields will increase in the coming years as more plants enter the production phase. (Coffee plants typically start producing cherries after three to four years.)

    Transport

    At 14.8 percent, transport is a major factor. This is mainly because workers and all equipment must be transported to the farm, as only two employees live on the farm. However, transport does not include the transport of coffee to the port. We calculate this separately along with shipping and transport within the EU.

    Roads in remote regions of Nicaragua cannot be compared to roads in Switzerland, and the additional effort caused by unevenness or lack of paving must be taken into account.

    Discussion

    Comparison of Emission Data for Green Coffees

    Existing environmental data for coffee vary greatly or are unavailable. Data in environmental databases such as Ecoinvent aim to provide high universality. Therefore, the focus is on producing countries such as Brazil, Vietnam, Colombia, Indonesia and Honduras, which account for 85 percent of global supply. The remaining 15 percent is distributed across another 55 producing countries and therefore receives less attention in large-scale studies.<2>

    For this reason, Ecoinvent does not have data for Nicaragua. Since Honduras is a neighboring country of Nicaragua and uses similar agricultural practices and coffee cultivation in Honduras is similar to cultivation structures in Nicaragua, a comparison makes sense. The Honduras data set shows 10.11 kg CO2e / kg green coffee<3>. The Carbon Cloud data set, a freely accessible database focused on food, shows 4.0 kg CO2e/kg green coffee<4> for coffee from Nicaragua. A study by Caravela Coffee, which also takes into account carbon retention by the agroforestry system, comes in at approximately -12.7 kg CO2e/kg green coffee<5>. The farm under consideration is thus in the middle range of these values. If land use change were taken into account at Santa Rita, approximately 4 kg CO2e/kg green coffee would have been retained at Santa Rita. This would only consider the area that is no longer managed as forest. Added to this would be new trees and shrubs such as bananas and Inga.

    Vergleich verschiedener Studien

    Comparison of Emission Data for Roasted Coffees

    The consideration of roasted coffees includes cultivation, transport and roasting (roasting in our calculation also includes packaging). To find reliable data for roasted coffee requires very close examination of studies and the data basis on which they are based. A frequently cited study <6> "Life cycle assessment synthesis of the carbon footprint of Arabica coffee: Case study of Brazil and Vietnam conventional and sustainable coffee production and export to the United Kingdom" shows a footprint for conventional coffee from Brazil for consumption in the UK of 14.61 kg CO2e / kg roasted coffee. However, the coffee in this study is airfreighted. Which is extremely rare.

    Ecoinvent offers no data. Carbon Cloud provides various data, but all of it is primarily based on coffee from Brazil. Thus the data are very similar.

    Vergleich verschiedener Datensaetze Studien

    Roasted Coffee from Santa Rita

    To calculate a footprint for coffees from the farm, we used two additional tools that we have developed ourselves as a company. A calculator for roastery carbon footprints based on Ecoinvent data and a transport calculator based on data from the Mobitool (as of 2023).

    Transport Emissionen vom Ursprung bis zu Rösterei mit Streckenangabe

    The 2022 carbon footprint for the Kaffeemacher roastery has already been published. The roastery's emissions for 2022 amount to 22,122 t CO2e, which corresponds to 0.45 kg CO2e /kg roasted coffee.

    Route des Kaffees aus Nicaragua

    Kaffeemacher purchased 4780 kg of coffee from Nicaragua in 2022. This also includes coffee from Santa Rita. Transport emissions amount to 2692.19 kg CO2e, of which the proportional amount for coffee from Santa Rita is approximately 150 kg CO2e and thus 0.56 kg CO2e /kg green coffee.

    For both farm emissions and transport emissions, an additional 15 percent roasting loss must be accounted for. This results in a CO₂ carbon footprint of 2.96 kg CO2e / kg roasted coffee for the kilogram of roasted coffee.


    Green coffee Roasted coffee Distribution
    Cultivation 1.57 1.85 62.50 %
    Transport 0.56 0.66 22.30 %
    Roastery 0.45 15.20 %
    Total 2.51 2.96 100 %
    Verteilung der Emissionen Santa Rita Roestkaffee

    What's Missing?

    The chain of coffee continues, because coffee is consumed by you at home after roasting and by us in restaurants. Some 250 gram bags are sent around the world by mail, and then brewed as a filter or espresso? What impact does that have? What effect does a thermoblock or a 2.5 liter boiler have on power consumption and your carbon footprint.

    We have looked into these questions. You will find the first draft, current status on our sustainability page.

    Missing a link or interested in our work in this area? Then sign up for our newsletter to stay up to date on further topics in this area.

    In the meantime, the 2022/23 harvest at Santa Rita has been brought in and the 2023/24 harvest is currently underway. We will therefore soon be able to expand the study data with additional years.

    If you have questions or find logical errors, please comment or write to us. Thanks in advance!

    Sources

    <1> https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.3152/147154606781765345, Status: 20.12.23

    <2> https://coffeebarometer.org/explore-coffee-barometer/, Status: 20.12.23

    <3> https://v38.ecoquery.ecoinvent.org/Details/PDF/90C86EF0-3AFE-4D85-8885-779EBE69FAD4/290C1F85-4CC4-4FA1-B0C8-2CB7F4276DCE, Status: 20.12.23

    <4> https://apps.carboncloud.com/climatehub/product-reports/id/74726502789, Status: 21.12.23

    <5> https://caravela.coffee/project/producing-greener-coffee-at-farm-level/#whitepaper, Status: 20.12.23

    <6> https://rgs-ibg.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/geo2.96, Status: 22.12.23

    What do you think?

      Which machine should we test next?

      Espresso machine or grinder: Tell us what should be next on our test bench. We read every request.

      We only use your email to follow up on your request. You'll only receive the newsletter if you check the box and confirm. Privacy Policy