What is the most sustainable coffee packaging? We switched our coffee bags from paper-plastic composite to mono-plastic. These are apparently considered more sustainable. But how sustainable are they really? We compared.
First, a heads up: there's still a long way to go to truly sustainable packaging. We found that the new packaging didn't change much, at least when it comes to our carbon footprint.
Once our packaging ran out, we faced the question: Can we improve in this area? After conversations with suppliers and online research, we decided on a mono-plastic packaging as a more sustainable solution.
In the meantime, we continued to search and stepped up our efforts in sustainability. Through our internal CO2 measurement, packaging became a focus again, as it accounts for roughly 55% of our roastery's emissions (The measurement already refers to the new packaging). That still corresponds to around 4% of emissions from the entire supply chain. (Based on an average of conventional coffees from Brazil between 2001-2014. Source: ecoinvent)
What is plastic?
Plastics are made from crude oil (also partly from natural gas).
Distilling crude oil produces raw gasoline, also called naphtha. This is turned into ethene, propene, and butene through cracking. Various plastics can be made from these. (There are different processes at each step, but we don't want to get into the details here.)
Mono-plastics for coffee packaging are typically plastics based on polyethylene (PE) or polypropylene (PP). They're considered sustainable because, unlike all composite materials (paper/plastic, plastic/plastic, aluminum/paper, etc.), they have one major advantage: they're recyclable.
This means composite packaging ends up in waste incineration, while mono-plastic packaging might not. Perhaps the argument for sustainable packaging is based mainly on this. So the big question is: how many of our packages actually get recycled and how?
Carbon Footprint: New vs. Old Packaging
You can find more on CO2 and climate change here, by the way. For clarity: CO2e stands for CO2 equivalents and converts the impact of all greenhouse gases into CO2.
This makes it easier for us to compare carbon footprints. But it also carries the risk of focusing too much on it, keyword: carbon tunnel (more on that another time.)
Carbon footprint of individual materials
First, we look at the emissions of individual materials. To be meaningful, it wouldn't be right to only consider the manufacturing of individual materials—we need to account for every processing step, as well as disposal.
So we rely here on ecoinvent, a life cycle assessment database used to create processes and procedures using LCAs (Life Cycle Assessments), and a study on "Climate Benefits of Material Recycling*)
| Material | Manufacturing emissions (kg CO2e) | Recycling emissions (kg CO2e) | Disposal/incineration emissions (kg CO2e) |
| LDPE |
2.14 |
0.7 |
2.7** |
| LLDPE |
1.91 |
0.7 |
2.7** |
| PP |
1.9 |
0.7 |
2.7** |
| PET | 2.83 | 0.7 | 2.7** |
| Glass* |
0.9 |
0.5 |
|
| Aluminum* |
11 |
0.4 |
0.2 |
| Paper & cardboard* |
1.1 |
0.7 |
0.2 |
So, for 1 kg of our mono-LDPE packaging (which corresponds to roughly 70 250g packs), 2.14 kg CO2e /kg is created in the manufacturing of raw material.
We couldn't find exact data for further processing, so we turn to a dataset in ecoinvent for packaging film production. So further processing adds 0.82 kg CO2e /kg.
We don't factor in another life cycle and the associated emissions. What we found is that sorting, washing, and melting generate an additional 0.7 kg CO2e per kg. (Source: ecoinvent) On top of that is further processing.
What is recycling?
Recycling reuses waste and returns it to the economic cycle. In Germany, recyclable materials are collected in yellow sacks and then processed further. This means they're sorted, cleaned (e.g., labels are removed), and then melted down so they can be reused. There's a distinction made here:
- Reuse: Reusable bottles can be refilled up to 50 times
- Material recycling: PET bottles can be melted down and made into new PET bottles
- Energy recovery: Waste incineration. This is not counted in the recycling rate
The sale of recyclable material abroad is counted in the quota.
Differences in recycling between Switzerland and Germany
In Germany, packaging waste is separated through a so-called dual system and collected nationwide ("yellow sack"). As a company, we're required to finance this system through contributions as a producer of packaged goods putting them on the market.
Switzerland is working on a nationwide collection and recycling system «Collection 2025». Currently, there's no uniform system here yet.
Note 1: In general, the incentive for plastic recycling is low because it costs more and is more resource-intensive than manufacturing new material.
Note 2: The recycling code is a marking that helps consumers sort their waste.
Detailed information on recycling can be found here.
Is mono-plastic better than PET?
Does mono-plastic have a recycling rate like PET bottles (92% ***) or does the quota of the German dual system (63% ****) apply, or the plastic packaging quota of Germany 2020 (46.2% *****) or the global quota from the OECD report (9% ******)?
What is the carbon footprint of the new packaging depending on the recycling rate?
We now calculate the carbon footprint depending on different recycling rates. We do this by proportionally excluding disposal from the calculation for further processing.
| Recycling rate | Emissions per kg (kg CO2e) | Emissions per package (kg CO2e) |
| 100.00% |
2.96 |
0.042 |
| 93.00% |
3.15 |
0.045 |
| 63.00% |
3.96 |
0.057 |
| 46.20% |
4.41 |
0.063 |
| 9.00% |
5.42 |
0.077 |
What do these numbers tell us? On their own, they just tell us that a high recycling rate is better than a low one. Fair enough.
Interim result: Our bag has a carbon footprint of 0.063 kg CO2e per bag at the current recycling rate in Germany
What is the footprint of the old bag?
Our old packaging consisted of:
| Material | Weight in g/m² | |
|
Paper |
40 |
27.97 % |
| PET |
16.8 |
11.75 % |
| PE |
76.8 |
53.71 % |
| Valve | 0.67 |
0.47 % |
| Adhesive and ink | 8.42 |
5.89 % |
| Zipper |
0.31 |
0.22 % |
| Total |
143 |
That equals 4.49 kg CO2e /kg, which corresponds to 0.064 kg CO2e per 250g pack
You can see that the paper component has a positive effect on the carbon footprint, since it generates a much lower footprint both in manufacturing and in incineration.
The more plastic in the packaging, the higher the emissions.
Are our new bags more sustainable than the old ones?
With the paper portion of the old packaging at 28% and the current recycling rate in Germany, we improved by 54g CO2e per kg of packaging. That's roughly 0.77g CO2e per 250g package.
| German recycling rate 2020 | Emissions old packaging |
Emissions new packaging |
| 46.20% |
64.257 |
63.481 |
However, transport isn't included in this analysis, and processing into mono-LDPE film appears to be more energy-efficient compared to manufacturing the stand-up pouch with zipper and valve.
What is the most sustainable coffee packaging?
We still haven't been able to answer the following questions, and new ones come up daily. We're working on it, gathering information, and regularly updating this blog. If you also have questions about sustainable coffee packaging, information, tips, and resources, please share them in the comments.
- What are realistic values for recycling coffee packaging?
- How does transport affect the carbon footprint?
- What are the actual emissions in packaging manufacturing?
- How many times can our packaging be recycled?
- What are the emissions for one recycling cycle?
- What are the life cycles of recycled materials and their carbon footprints?
We also haven't considered what other impacts plastic has (environmental pollution, water consumption, land use change, etc.), and even if it doesn't end up in incineration, the negative effects on the environment are enormous. Here, the global OECD recycling rate is alarming and becomes even more so when you look at global plastic production of 367 million tons *******.
So our goal must be to avoid plastic where we can and, whenever possible, sort waste properly to achieve high recycling rates.
We've recently started using the new packaging and, while these packages are still in retention, we're searching for better alternatives suitable for our coffee. Compostable PLA? Bio-PE, single-use or reusable glass, paper?
Sources
* Hillman, "Climate Benefits of Material Recycling", 2015, as of: 18.11.22
** DIW, "Auf dem Weg zur Klimaneutralität: Plastikrecycling muss stärker in den Fokus rücken", 30.06.21, as of: 18.11.22
*** BVSE, "PET BEVERAGE BOTTLES: HIGH RECYCLING RATE AND INCREASING USE OF RECYCLED MATERIAL", Nov. 20, as of: 18.11.22
**** Nörr, "Hat das Duale System beim Plastik-Recycling versagt?", 14.02.2022, as of: 18.11.22
***** Burger, "Aufkommen und Verwertung von Verpackungsabfällen in Deutschland im Jahr 2020", Sept. 2022, as of: 18.11.22
****** Zeit, Nur neun Prozent des weltweit verwendeten Plastiks wird recycelt, 22.02.2022, as of: 18.11.22
******* Statista: "Weltweite und europäische Kunststoffproduktion in den Jahren von 1950 bis 2020", 2022, as of: 18.11.22
















