"Strong and weak", "mild and bitter" are probably the most heard pairs of opposites that coffee drinkers use to describe their coffee. Some coffee experts consider these terms useless. Unfortunately, that's not true and is rather elitist.
In recent years, coffee farmers, importers, roasters, baristas, bloggers, restaurateurs, scientists, etc. have made the specialty coffee industry more colorful, but also more confusing for the uninitiated. We get more coffee variety, more stories, and more individual expressions of beverages.
Questions that every café with quality aspirations must ask itself today are:
- How do we convey all the knowledge we've gained to average coffee drinkers?
- Which descriptions do we use?
- Which coffee serves us as a reference to make the differences clear?
- How do we avoid overwhelming consumers in the process?
What follows is a mini-explanation model that doesn't overwhelm consumers but still makes them curious about more background information – if they want it
Strong and weak coffee
The majority of coffee drinkers define coffee by intensity. The natural reaction of coffee professionals would probably be: "Well, which intensity?" A justified question, knowing that acidity, sweetness, body, etc. are examined not only for intensity but also for quality.
So does it make sense if I explain to a coffee drinker the differences between quality and intensity, with the best knowledge that this also causes confusion among coffee professionals again and again?
Let's just get into this intensity discussion. The statement "this coffee is strong (or weak)" is not nearly as one-dimensional as it sounds. You can answer this statement clearly with "yes" or "no" and then immediately elaborate, because: there are at least three reasons why the coffee might be strong/weak:
- Ratio of coffee to water (recipe)
- Agitation, time, temperature, pressure (brewing method)
- Solubility of the coffee (roast)
Now we have three topics (recipe, brewing method, roast) as a basis for entering into a more in-depth conversation with the consumer about quality.
Mild and bitter
"Mild" and "bitter" are probably the second most common descriptions for coffee. In sensory training, I always ask participants what they understand by "mild". Answers like these are the rule: "fine aromas, fine flavors, nothing disturbing, no acidity, harmonious." When asked what the opposite of mild would be, the most common answer given is: "bitter".
How do we deal with this?
We have some imprecise descriptions, but also a helpful pair of opposites: bitter – mild.
To illustrate this, we usually do an experiment with an optimally extracted filter coffee A (TDS approximately 1.25, extraction rate approximately 20%), and an over-extracted filter coffee B (TDS approximately 1.25, extraction rate approximately 25%). So far, most participants prefer coffee A, it is "mild and harmonious". Coffee B in comparison is "bitter", "unbalanced" or even "aggressive".
If we expand our y-axis by an x-axis, the following simple chart emerges, which everyone can understand and follow with a bit of explanation:
We're still not being overly technical here, haven't described the coffee either lexically (variety, origin, processing) or in terms of content (flavor notes, body, acidity, etc.). And yet we were able to convey more information – information that includes rather than excludes the average coffee drinker.
We don't need to reinvent sensory communication. We advocate meeting consumers with the terminology they use, while defining it more precisely. And suddenly "weak" and "strong" become a complex matter.
















