Home / Coffee knowledge / What influence does the tamping pressure have on the espresso?
    Espresso
    Welchen Einfluss hat der Druck beim Tampen auf den Espresso?

    What influence does the tamping pressure have on the espresso?

    The tamping pressure when tamping has little influence on espresso extraction. We wanted to scientifically validate this finding from daily practice. For this purpose, we worked with the support of a food technologist to extract, measure, and vary the tamping pressure on 150 espressos. In this article, we present the results to you.

    What is Tamping?

    Tamping is the pressing of ground coffee powder in the portafilter. A tamper is used for "tamping," which consists of a handle and a metal base that is pressed into the portafilter like a piston. The metal base corresponds to the inner diameter of the basket. If the gap between the basket wall and tamper diameter is too large, part of the coffee powder will not be pressed sufficiently.

    By pressing the ground coffee, uniform water distribution is enabled. The brewing water should encounter the same resistance on the ground coffee surface at all contact points. If the ground coffee is not compacted enough in places or if there are air pockets below the pressing point, there is a risk of channeling. This can be prevented through careful preparation of the ground coffee, vertical compacting, and even tamping.

    Instructions: Preparing Espresso Step by Step (Articles and Videos).

    three tampers

    Three classic tampers with a 58mm diameter.

    Research Question: What Influence Does Tamping Pressure Have?

    Two aspects were examined. First, we wanted to find out whether changing tamping pressure affects the flow time. Second, we investigated whether tamping pressure has an effect on extraction yield and thus on the concentration of dissolved coffee particles in the cup.

    To obtain the most precise results possible, work steps and methodology were defined precisely.

    Materials

    Rancilio Specialty, commercial espresso machine with precise flowmeter. However, each espresso shot was double-checked with the Acaia Luna.

    Etzinger etzMax, espresso grinder with integrated scale. However, all grinds were rechecked by weight and repeated if there was a deviation (see methodology).

    Puqpress, automatic tamping machines for commercial use. Tamping pressure adjustable.

    VST Refractometer, for measuring TDS in percent, that is, the concentration of dissolved particles in the beverage in relation to water.

    VST Syringe Filter Attachment, to filter solids from coffee solution and measure only the dissolved particles with the refractometer.

    VST Syringe

    etzmax and puqpress

    Etzmax Espresso Grinder and Puqpress

    Methods

    The espresso grinder is set to an output of 18.5 g. Ground coffee results between 18.4 g and 18.6 g are used.

    The Rancilio Specialty espresso machine is programmed to an output water amount of 45 ml and a brewing temperature of 93 °C.

    The corresponding amount of coffee is ground directly into the portafilter. The coffee is then leveled with fingers and tamped with the Puqpress. The portafilter is locked into the machine and extraction begins.

    The amount in the espresso cup is measured on the scale. After extraction, the portafilter is removed and tapped out.

    A flush shot is pulled on the espresso machine.

    After extraction, the espressos are set aside to cool. After cooling, they are stirred and the TDS value is measured with the refractometer.

    The espresso is drawn into the refractometer through the syringe filter attachment using the syringe.

    This procedure is repeated 50 times each for tamping pressures of 10 kg, 15 kg, and 20 kg.

    Data evaluation for flow time and TDS values is performed using a one-way ANOVA with a specified error probability of 5%.

    Results Flow Time and Tamping Pressure

    In the variance analysis of flow time, no significant difference could be found. In other words: regardless of whether pressing was done at 10 kg, 15 kg, or 20 kg, our measurements did not vary noticeably due to pressing pressure.

    Effect of tamping on extraction time

    Effect of tamping pressure on extraction time.

    10 kg Pressure 15 kg Pressure 20 kg Pressure
    26 20 27
    21 23 25
    23 26 29
    24 27 28
    23 25 24
    24 26 27
    25 26 23
    24 29 25
    26 20 26
    31 24 27
    25 23 25
    24 23 21
    25 22 26
    27 23 21
    24 30 24
    24 24 21
    25 22 24
    27 21 25
    23 21 28
    31 24 22
    25 24 22
    24 25 24
    22 30 23
    27 20 25
    22 21 22
    25 23 25
    25 21 21
    24 21 22
    24 27 21
    23 22 24
    27 23 22
    21 22 30
    24 24 21
    25 21 25
    24 25 29
    25 24 26
    23 24 23
    23 23 24
    23 23 24
    22 23 23
    21 22 24
    26 24 26
    23 25 24
    25 22 20
    24 23 27
    20 23 22
    24 26 25
    24 22 26
    22 21 22
    23 24 20
    Time measurements in seconds
    Groups Count Sum Average Variance
    Column 1 50 1212 24,24 4,51265306
    Column 2 50 1177 23,54 5,60040816
    Column 3 50 1210 24,2 6,08163265
    Summary
    Source of Variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
    Between Groups 15,4533333 2 7,72666667 1,43133301 0,242301 3,05762065
    Within Groups 793,54 147 5,39823129
    Total 808,993333 149
    ANOVA
    Fk(0,05) 3,05762065


    The test statistic F is smaller than the critical F value, so there is no significant result. The actual P value exceeds the specified error probability of 5%. Therefore, no significant difference can be found between the groups.

    Results TDS Values and Tamping Pressure

    In the variance analysis of TDS values, no significant difference could be found either. The concentration of dissolved coffee particles was not substantially affected by different tamping pressures.

    Effect of tamping

    Effect of tamping pressure on concentration of dissolved particles.

    10 kg Pressing 15 kg Pressing 20 kg Pressing
    8,53 7,77 8,15
    7,99 7,94 8,15
    8,03 8,02 8,16
    8,13 8,03 8,27
    8,01 8,08 8,2
    8,01 8,06 8,08
    8,1 8,07 8,08
    8,05 8,26 8,01
    8,2 8,12 7,96
    8,24 7,96 8,03
    8,17 7,98 7,99
    8,15 7,99 8,03
    7,91 7,85 8,11
    8,09 8,02 8,02
    8,09 8,88 8,02
    8,09 8,12 8,01
    8,11 8,11 7,93
    8,15 7,99 8,04
    7,96 7,99 8,04
    8,3 8,05 7,99
    8,25 8,15 7,99
    7,99 8,2 8
    8,07 8,28 7,99
    7,99 7,81 8
    7,81 7,84 7,97
    7,8 7,92 8,01
    7,93 7,9 8,01
    7,94 7,87 7,66
    7,86 7,97 7,8
    7,93 7,88 7,89
    8,06 8,02 7,99
    8,08 8,02 8,02
    7,99 7,95 7,92
    8,04 7,7 7,99
    8,05 7,89 *
    8,13 8,01 *
    8,2 8,11 *
    8,19 7,95 7,91
    7,98 8,02 7,96
    7,94 8,07 7,7
    7,82 7,94 8,01
    8,08 8,04 8,08
    8,08 8,05 7,92
    8,07 7,96 7,83
    8,06 7,97 8,03
    7,88 7,78 7,97
    7,88 8,01 7,97
    7,93 7,81 7,91
    7,97 7,73 7,65
    7,96 7,85 7,69
    TDS values. *missing measurement values in these cells

    TDS values. *missing measurement values in these cells

    Groups Count Sum Average Variance
    Column 1 50 402,27 8,0454 0,01824167
    Column 2 50 399,99 7,9998 0,03163465
    Column 3 47 375,14 7,98170213 0,01635356
    Summary
    Source of Variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
    Between Groups 0,10546284 2 0,05273142 2,37573217 0,0965805 3,058928
    Within Groups 3,19620383 144 0,02219586
    Total 3,30166667 146
    ANOVA
    Fk 0,05 3,058928
    Fk 0,1 2,33979948

    The test statistic F is smaller than the critical F value, so there is no significant result. The actual P value exceeds the specified error probability of 5%. Therefore, no significant difference can be found between the groups.

    Raw Data and Measurements from the Tamping Test

    The raw data and further information can be found in the Excel sheet. If you can derive any further interesting insights, we would love to hear about the results.

    Download Tamping Project Results

    Analysis of the data revealed a linear correlation between the following datasets for extraction time and the determined TDS values, which was determined using the Bravais-Pearson correlation coefficient:

    • Tamping pressure 10 kg: Extraction time and TDS: weak positive correlation -> r=0.5068
    • Tamping pressure 15 kg: Extraction time and TDS: strong positive correlation -> r=0.6854
    • Tamping pressure 20 kg: Extraction time and TDS: weak positive correlation -> r=0.5423

    where: |r|=1 -> perfect linear correlation

    |r|=0 -> no linear correlation

    Pressing Pressure, Taste, and Additional Information

    Within the scope of this test, the taste of the espresso was not examined. Therefore, we cannot make any statements about it. However, based on the insights from the test, we interpret that varying pressing pressure in the range we examined has no or only marginal influence on taste.

    Also, based on our test, we cannot make any statement about how pressure lower than 10 kilograms affects extraction. Based on research and partner feedback as well as our own experience, we recommend pressing with at least 6 kilograms of pressure when tamping.

    Discussion

    In examining the question of whether tamping pressure affects the extraction time of espressos, no influence could be demonstrated. However, this does not mean that no influence exists, only that in the test model used, no influence could be demonstrated. Interfering factors include, for example, inaccuracies in preparation and insufficient precision of the examination machines used.

    The equipment used is designed for professional use in gastronomy and not for precise laboratory equipment.

    However, there are far greater interfering factors in practice when preparing an espresso than in the experimental procedure used.

    Therefore, in practice, we should not assume a major influence of tamping pressure on extraction, since there are many inconsistent parameters affecting the extraction process. In this, tamping pressure is merely one parameter among many.

    ---

    The tamping test was conducted by Michel Aeschbacher in collaboration with a food technologist who wishes to remain unnamed. We are grateful for your contribution!

    We are open to further research partnerships and are happy to use our materials and expertise to develop insights on all things coffee-related.

    What do you think?

      Which machine should we test next?

      Espresso machine or grinder: Tell us what should be next on our test bench. We read every request.

      We only use your email to follow up on your request. You'll only receive the newsletter if you check the box and confirm. Privacy Policy