Home / Coffee knowledge / Direct Trade Coffee: Anyone can say it, no one has to prove it
    Kaffeemarkt
    Direct Trade Kaffee: Jeder darf es sagen, niemand muss es belegen

    Direct Trade Coffee: Anyone can say it, no one has to prove it

    There is neither a rulebook nor an inspection authority for Direct Trade. There is also no definition that two roasters would need to agree on. Nevertheless, the term appears on thousands of coffee packages, and no one questions what direct trade actually means. Rather, it's a feeling that makes for a good hiding place. What we need is precision, otherwise the good principles will be lost.

    In short: What is Direct Trade coffee?

    Direct Trade refers to the direct purchase of raw coffee from producers, without anonymous intermediary stages. The term emerged in the early 2000s among some US roasters as a response to a world market price of 41 US cents per pound. To this day, there is no seal, certification body, or binding definition. Each roaster decides for themselves what it means, but no one checks it.

    "Is your coffee actually Direct Trade?"

    The question came up in one of my roasting courses. "Your coffee is surely Direct Trade, isn't it?" I answered the way I have for years: in a convoluted way, with digressions, with many ifs and buts. My answer wasn't very satisfying for my conversation partner.

    "Well," I usually say then, "there's no definition of exactly how direct 'direct' is."

    When you pick up a coffee package today, you encounter terms like Relationship Coffee, Farm Direct, Ethical Sourcing, Direct Trade, fairer than Fairtrade, or all of them at once. Each of these terms sounds like closeness, but none of them say anything as long as there's no number or concrete facts behind them. Relationship Coffee means little if no one takes on any risk. Farm Direct conceals the fact that there are almost always multiple players between farm and roaster; someone handles logistics, someone handles insurance, someone handles financing, someone handles storage. Ethical Sourcing remains a feeling without concrete, measurable criteria.

    Ask a handful of roasters what belongs to direct trade. The answers will be shorter or longer. But none will be the same.

    Where Direct Trade comes from and what the term once meant

    September 2001. The coffee price falls to 41 US cents per pound, the lowest real value in a hundred years. Small farmers can no longer service their debts, farms are abandoned.

    Responding to this situation, a few US roasters argued that quality could be a way out. Intelligentsia, Counter Culture, Stumptown. They drove to the farms, donated cupping courses so that producers learned how their own coffee tasted, and tied the price to taste and quality instead of the stock exchange. Intelligentsia set itself a benchmark: at least 25 percent above the Fairtrade minimum price, and completely transparent about it. Stumptown gave itself the rule that a coffee could only be called Direct Trade after three consecutive years.

    Why there was never a rulebook for direct trade

    There was no audit, no paperwork, and no certification body. The idea of self-regulation applied. Three companies defined for themselves what they meant, and talked to each other about it—that was everything at the beginning. Today it's not just a handful of roasters, but thousands worldwide. Self-regulation remained, but no one checks each other anymore.

    Directly traded coffee is not the same as Direct Trade

    Lennart Clerkx founded This Side Up in 2013 in the Netherlands. Really, he just wanted to organize dialogue between producers and roasters, but transportation proved to be the bottleneck, and so the mediation became an importer. Today they buy themselves, bear the risk, and finance roasters in advance.

    For Lennart, the central question isn't who knows whom, but where the power lies. Whoever has the capital to execute the trade has the power. And the moment a middleman exists, dependency is created.

    This leads to a distinction that hardly anyone in the industry makes.

    What Lennart calls directwashing

    When This Side Up buys coffee directly from a producer, that's Direct Trade. If a roaster then buys this coffee from This Side Up, they've purchased directly traded coffee. But they haven't themselves engaged in direct trade. They're retelling someone else's relationship work as their own.

    This isn't semantic hairsplitting. Either someone buys for me, or I do it myself. Lennart calls it the most common abuse he sees, and he also explains why it bothers him: whoever passes off someone else's work as their own undercuts the very roasters who actually do that work.

    Why we don't call ourselves Direct Trade, even though we could

    We buy through algrano, This Side Up, Falcon, Plot Coffee, Ensambles and several others. We've pre-financed coffees. We've also imported ourselves, complete with export papers, even though we're not logistics experts. By common definitions, some of our coffees would qualify as Direct Trade coffees. We just don't say so because for most of our coffees we're freeloaders: others organize logistics and storage, and we only pay when we take delivery of the raw coffee.

    Read where and how much coffee we buy in our transparency report.

    Coffee is prepared for export in Ocotal, Nicaragua.

    Is there a Direct Trade seal?

    No. There is no certification body, no logo, no testing standard, and from everything I hear, there won't be one.

    Andreas Felsen, whom everyone calls Pingo, co-founded Quijote Kaffee in 2010 in Hamburg and is one of Germany's pioneers of direct trade. I asked him whether such a Direct Trade certification body could ever come. His answer was a clear no, because, as Pingo says: Roasters who have lived this culture for years have already earned their credibility. A third-party seal wouldn't be a marketing tool for them, but rather a negative image transfer. Quijote deliberately forgoes the organic and Fairtrade seals for the same reason.

    A common rulebook fails for him one level earlier. The industry's interests are too far apart, particularly in how the term itself is used.

    Why many don't mind Fairtrade and Direct Trade at all?

    There are doctoral theses about Fairtrade, consumer magazines, newspaper articles, entire websites full of criticism. Rightly so, that belongs to a system that makes promises.

    I asked Pingo if he knows a single consumer magazine that has critically examined Direct Trade. He knows none from Europe. He knows forums from the US, but in Japan direct trade seems to be questioned much more critically than it is here.

    Funny enough, the explanation is quite simple; Fairtrade has a seal. A seal is a promise, a promise is verifiable, and what's verifiable can be broken. Direct Trade makes no verifiable promise, so there's nothing to break.

    Whoever makes no promise can't break their word.

    That's the semantic black market we've made ourselves comfortable in. I can write that I trade ethically, and no one corrects me. I can write that this coffee is fairer than Fairtrade, and no one corrects me.

    Are middlemen in coffee trade really the problem?

    In almost every narrative about direct trade, the middleman is the figure to be excluded. Often they're called coyotes, and those who are so named get no sympathy.

    Some are. Whoever just holds out an empty hand, provides no added value, and creates dependency in the process is a bad deal that can be avoided.

    Others master microeconomies. They handle local logistics, they pay cash when no one else buys. There are door-closers, and there are door-openers.

    What that looks like, you can see with Yulma Argueta. She didn't start growing coffee until she was forty in Baja Verapaz, Guatemala, and sold her first harvests locally without knowing how good her coffee actually was. We were able to help her export for the first time in 2025. So she wouldn't depend only on us, we networked her with several exporters. Now she exports twice as much as she did last year.

    Lennart said in our conversation that so much of how coffee trade is set up today is based on colonialism. If you want to learn more about coffee and colonialism, I recommend this podcast with Christian Cwik from the University of Graz.

    The coffee chain is long. Coffee passes through many hands before it reaches the cup. A walk around a farm in the Sierra de Zongolica, Mexico.

    How to recognize authentic Direct Trade: five questions for every roaster

    Because there's no rulebook for direct coffee trade, I've created one. Not an official one, but one based on what people who mean it say. I'm giving you five questions that you should be able to answer on every website.

    1
    Who built the relationship? Does it say who selected the coffee and nurtured the relationship, or is an importer's work being retold?
    2
    Since when? Is there a year, and is it more than one harvest?
    3
    Who bears the risk? Is there a real relationship behind the coffee? Is some of it pre-financed, is it still purchased in a bad harvest, and how are price fluctuations handled?
    4
    Is there a number? An FOB price, a differential on the C-price, something verifiable. Or just the word transparency?
    5
    Who defined the criteria, and where are they published?

    We applied the test to ourselves. So are the Kaffeemacher Direct Trade?

    The self-test: Kaffeemacher, five questions

    Question 1: partially passed. Most of our coffees come through importers, but the relationship emerged between us and producers. Often importers like algrano then take on the pre-financing, logistics, and storage. But we also repeatedly buy coffees from importers who offer us coffee from producers we don't know.

    Question 2: mixed. Our average relationship duration is 4.52 years, which sounds solid. Only 37 percent of our partnerships have been running for three years or longer. By Stumptown's own rule, almost two-thirds of our coffees shouldn't be called "direct trade" since Stumptown only speaks of long-term relationships after three years.

    Question 3: partially passed. Finca Santa Rita in Nicaragua we ran ourselves from 2017 to 2025. With the Toca project in the Sierra de Zongolica, we became partners through a co-investment by buyers. With most other coffees, someone else bears the risk.

    Question 4: passed. We publish our raw coffee prices since 2020. In 2025/26 our average FOB price was 5.76 USD per pound unweighted and 4.81 USD weighted, over 129,110 kilograms and 43 producers in 16 countries.

    Question 5: failed. However: we develop criteria case by case, because every coffee partnership is different.

    By this 5-point test, we wouldn't be a Direct Trade roaster, and we don't say we are anywhere. But we say what we do, and if someone interprets that as direct trade, they're welcome to. How we work, what matters to us, how we build and maintain relationships, design visions together with producers—we describe that in our transparency report.

    Does coffee become better through Direct Trade?

    Not automatically. Pingo distinguished it clearly. Where Quijote is really on the ground, in Honduras, where Stephi travels two or three times a year, and in Ecuador, where he regularly goes himself, quality has developed together over the years. And in the two high-price years when many producers sold their coffee expensively anyway and weren't particularly loyal suppliers, Quijote got its usual quality. But even that's not an automatic process, he says himself. It takes engagement, constant exchange, and the roaster also has to speak up if something doesn't work.

    Behind this lies a claim I think is the weakest in the whole field: that higher quality leads to higher income. Higher sales prices, yes. But high quality costs vastly more work, and who actually says what good quality is?

    For years there was a scorecard that the world calibrated to. The world? Most producers to this day don't know how their coffee tastes. And this scorecard appears neutral but is full of subjective judgments. If a point score at the end decides whether a coffee is purchased, then the argument doesn't hold up.

    Many producers don't know how their own coffee tastes. We brought the Romão family in Castelo, Brazil, their own coffee back. Roasted.

    Direct Trade was an answer to 41 cents per pound of raw coffee. Today we're at many times that

    Here lies the blind spot of the whole debate for me. The founding logic of direct trade was an answer to a market at rock bottom. Because the exchange offered nothing, quality was supposed to be a second path, at least for the few producers who had either the luck, social, or cultural capital to come into contact with quality-oriented roasters in the first place. Intelligentsia's 25 percent above the Fairtrade minimum price were formulated in a world where this minimum price actually mattered.

    On February 12, 2025, Arabica stood at over 442 US cents per pound, an all-time high, more than five times the long-term average. In early June 2026 it was around 250. In eighteen months the C-price swung between 270 and 440.

    In such a market, producers in Brazil, Mexico, India, and Indonesia prefer to sell domestically rather than for export, because cash flows quickly locally. They hold back coffee and influence prices with it. They understand how speculation works.

    What do they need a roaster for then, who visits once a year? I don't have a ready answer for that. I just think we owe them one, as long as we keep justifying Direct Trade with arguments from 2001.

    What that says about coffee trade

    To be fair: something has moved, and in a place hardly anyone's aware of. Pingo tells us that the Transparent Trade network has developed a kind of definitional power within the industry. Roasters approached importers wanting to know how much of their money actually reaches the destination. The demand for transparency increased significantly, though from roasters and not from consumers.

    As long as transparency is asked from behind, it works. The moment it's sold from the front, it becomes vague. Pingo calls it low-hanging fruit, and he's right: it takes little effort to know where your coffee comes from.

    What the EUDR changes about that

    When traceability becomes legally mandatory, a term that voluntarily promises it loses its value as a unique selling point. What then remains as a distinctive feature is the question of price and risk. But those are precisely the points Direct Trade has never binding regulated.

    Let's call directly what it deserves

    Lennart is currently working to make himself superfluous. This Side Up no longer just guides roasters toward direct trade, but also producers. In Colombia, an eight-year partnership with his local partner has resulted in him now doing all the sales himself. The next step is for him to build his own import company in the Netherlands. Lennart could keep this relationship, but he's spinning it out.

    I find that as clever as it is admirable, and it shows where this could go.

    We're currently looking at what role rulesets can play that producers create for themselves. Participatory guarantee systems work from the bottom up, they adapt to local conditions, and they don't need a certification authority in Europe. Whether that works, we don't yet know.

    Conclusion

    There won't be a Direct Trade bible. The particular interests are too great. But what can exist are declarations of intent that cost something. And discussions that sharpen the term rather than continue to soften it.

    Test a few roasters who proclaim Direct Trade with the five suggested questions. That way we all get certainty about where more precision is needed and where the wheat is separated from the chaff.


    Frequently asked questions about Direct Trade coffee

    What does Direct Trade mean for coffee?

    The direct purchase of raw coffee from producers or cooperatives, without anonymous intermediary stages. The term emerged in the early 2000s among US roasters like Intelligentsia, Counter Culture, and Stumptown. No binding definition exists; each roaster decides for themselves what it means.

    Is there a Direct Trade seal?

    No. There is no unified official Direct Trade logo, no certification body, and no testing standard for direct trade. Unlike Fairtrade or organic, no one checks whether the claim is true. Whoever uses the term defines the criteria themselves.

    Is Direct Trade better than Fairtrade?

    Fair coffee trade comes from the same reasoning as direct coffee trade—that the coffee price is repeatedly too low. But the two systems solve different problems. Fairtrade secures a floor price and is externally audited. Direct Trade aims for quality, relationship, and higher prices, but is non-binding and not audited.

    What does Direct Trade mean for taste?

    Does coffee become better through direct trade? No, not automatically. Regular, honest exchange between roaster and producer can improve the quality and taste of directly traded coffee over years if both sides invest. Direct purchasing alone doesn't do this.

    What is directwashing?

    The term comes from Lennart Clerkx and describes roasters who buy directly traded coffee from an importer and present their relationship work as their own. The coffee was directly traded, but the roaster themselves didn't engage in direct trade.

    How do I recognize authentic Direct Trade?

    By verifiable information: Who built the relationship, how long has it existed, who bears the financial risk, is an FOB price mentioned, and are the roaster's criteria publicly available somewhere?

    Transcript of podcast episode 86 expanded

    DIRECT TRADE — WHO DOES DIRECT TRADE BENEFIT?
    Kaffeemacher Podcast, edited transcript

    ======================================================================

    This is the transcript of this podcast episode, edited and cleaned of filler words. The spoken style is retained. The English original comments from Lennart Clerkx and César Marín stand as original.

    I'm repeatedly asked whether our coffee is Direct Trade. My answer has always been convoluted and multilayered. And I notice that I'm slightly disappointing my conversation partner. The way we communicate and present ourselves—isn't that already Direct Trade? Yes, I say then usually, there's just no precise definition of exactly how direct Direct is.

    Latest in such a conversation it becomes clear that this term became extremely loaded and deeply imprecise, even misused. Ask a handful of roasters and coffee drinkers what all belongs to direct trade. The answers will be shorter or longer, but never the same. A common denominator would probably be that direct trade is based on acquaintance between producers and roasters. Okay, I would then say, but what's your acquaintance? A shared photo on Instagram? A wave from afar, a handshake, herding pigs together, or even having lived through crises together?

    Direct Trade unfortunately can't be answered that quickly. Especially not when everyone imagines something different by it. So in this podcast I set out to search for the original meaning, the rulebook, today's interpretation, the claims, and especially the question of who actually benefits from Direct Trade and who doesn't.

    This is the Kaffeemacher Podcast. I'm Philipp Schallberger, welcome.

    LET'S START WITH PRICE
    ------------------------

    Really, Direct Trade is fundamentally about the question of whether the money you as consumers pay and the money roasters pay actually reaches where it's intended. So it's about money and prices. And we have to start there.

    The coffee price today, in April 2026, is around 280 to 300 cents per pound. It's risen sharply for about a year and a half and has fallen back somewhat. But let's look back. In the 1980s the coffee price was around 130 cents per pound. In September 2001 it fell to 41 US cents per pound during the so-called Coffee Crisis. That was the lowest real value in a hundred years and the result of price decline over four years.

    What happened? Vietnam massively and quickly invested in intensive Robusta production in the nineties. Brazil also made rapid progress in how much coffee could be harvested and processed. This resulted around the turn of the century in massive price drops. 41 cents per pound. The price fell because oversupply was too great. Real production costs aren't reflected by the exchange price—they're of course much higher. So there were job losses, poverty, and rural exodus. Small farmers couldn't service their debts anymore and had to abandon or sell farms.

    This crisis led to intensive debate about fair trade and the need for diversification in coffee growing. Fairtrade, which everyone knows today, set a minimum price in 1988—a floor. From 1988 to 2007 the Fairtrade minimum price was 176 cents per pound. So whoever could sell through Fairtrade channels during the coffee crisis had a floor. According to various studies, though, only 13 percent of Fairtrade-certified harvest actually got sold under Fairtrade conditions. Demand collapsed because for many roasters it was clear: if there's cheap coffee available, why pay more? Just because it's Fairtrade?

    THE BIRTH OF DIRECT TRADE
    ----------------------------------

    That was the birth of Direct Trade. There were a few roasters in the US who wanted to buy and roast high-quality specialty coffees. The argument was that for the first time there was reason to invest in quality. Because if prices are that low, then quality can be a path for producers who have the necessary social capital to address a different market.

    These pioneer roasters included Intelligentsia, Counter Culture, and Stumptown Coffee. These roasters personally drove to farms and built relationships. There were others who did this, and there were others who did it earlier. But these three communicated loudly and clearly about their intention.

    There was no audit. There was no paperwork. There was no certification body. The roasters argued that regular purchasing creates a relationship. Stumptown has its own rule that a coffee can only be called Direct Trade after three consecutive years. You had to know each other. And so the pioneers of direct trade drove to coffee-producing countries. From the US you're quickly in Central America, so it's no surprise that the first Direct Trade relationships were all Central American producers.

    The basic idea was to link quality and direct contact. Cupping—the evaluation of quality through tasting—became the key to quality understanding. And so many Direct Trade pioneers donated cupping courses so producers learned their coffee's quality. They tied price to quality, not the exchange. Intelligentsia early set its own benchmark, saying it would buy at least 25 percent above the Fairtrade minimum price and be fully transparent about it.

    You see: Through Fairtrade there was a floor as a reaction to the low exchange price. And then came the idea that quality should be rewarded. That would be the ceiling—in quotes. It's really more of an escape route, since not everyone could produce really good quality. I'll come back to that. But nothing was certified or checked. The idea of self-regulation applied. These pioneers set their own standards.

    Looking at the coffee world today, I don't see just a handful of roasters in the US anymore, but thousands worldwide who've committed to buying coffee as directly as possible—directly from the producer. Some say this is fairer and that coffee becomes better this way. The problem: who can actually check that and what exactly can be checked?

    To this day there's no universal definition of what Direct Trade is. This leads to suddenly lots of people doing Direct Trade even though they're buying coffee very indirectly. So: what relevance does Direct Trade have today? What's true, what's copied, what's marketing—and who actually benefits from Direct Trade? In the end, might it be the roasters who hope for profit from an undefined concept, while producers just take the hit?

    I'm trying to do justice to this topic as objectively as possible. But you can already see: it's really multilayered. We ourselves roast coffee and we avoid Direct Trade in communication. Though I'd say much of what we do would qualify as Direct Trade by common definitions.

    THE VOCABULARY OF CLOSENESS
    ----------------------

    Directly from the farm. Relationship Coffee. Fairer than Fairtrade. Whoever picks up a coffee package these days probably encounters one of these terms or all three at once. Direct trade is part of the basic vocabulary of the specialty industry. And that's exactly the problem. Because what's really communicated as direct today?

    It's an incomplete list of terms that say much but actually nothing if they're not backed by numbers. Relationship Coffee sounds human but means nothing if no price and risk-taking stands behind it. Farm Direct conceals a bit that there are usually multiple players between farm and roaster. Because you need someone who does logistics. Someone who does insurance and financing. And someone who might even be a storage company. Ethical Sourcing sounds really good, but without criteria it's not a concept but rather a feeling. Transparency, meanwhile, is a term used very frequently. It matters when it's backed by numbers and not just mentioned as a term.

    You see the central pattern: it's about suggesting closeness. But often responsibility is simply avoided with transparent information.

    WHO HAS THE POWER?
    ------------------

    I spoke with Lennart Clerkx from This Side Up, a Dutch raw coffee importer. Lennart founded it in 2013. His idea was that direct dialogue between producers and roasters would improve coffee quality, create fair treatment, and ultimately deliver competitive products. He also saw the bottleneck: transport. It's expensive when you buy small quantities. And so This Side Up became an importer, though they didn't want to initially. They now buy coffee themselves, bear the risk, and help finance roasters. Whoever buys coffee from This Side Up buys directly traded coffee, says Lennart.

    "The definition is hard. Whether somebody does the transport, or whether somebody owns the relationship – all of that, I think, is secondary to who has the power in the relationship. Any middleman, however much freedom and however much transparency they give: because they have the financial means to execute the trade, they hold the power in the end. So you create dependency the moment there is a middleman there. Direct trade is when that power is dispersed between the roaster and the grower equally, when they become dependent on each other for each other's success.

    That is actually the reason I started This Side Up as a direct trade facilitator: being a development economist, power was the most interesting aspect I saw. That's the problem in the industry. We can talk about living income and fair trade and all this crap, but in the end – who is allowing more money to go to origin? Who, by the grace of their goodness and good deeds, is allowing a bit more money to go there? There is nobody willing to give up power in the industry, and that is why direct trade is so important."

    So for Lennart it's about power distribution. Who has power in the coffee chain? And he speaks of the middleman, a figure that in many narratives should be excluded. But that's far too short-sighted and unfortunately isn't questioned. Often it's said: middlemen are bad, so you must work directly with producers. But who can actually work really directly with producers so it's worth it for them? And are middlemen really always bad?

    It's like this: if a link in the chain just holds out an empty hand, provides no added value, and creates dependency to boot, then it's naturally a bad deal. This kind of middleman can be dispensed with, if that's possible. But often these middlemen simply fill a gap, and they master microeconomies. Maybe they handle local logistics or buy coffee for cash, give cash flow when no one else would buy. Or they can be harmful. These middlemen are often called coyotes—and by being named disparagingly, they can hardly be viewed sympathetically. Sure, there are door-closers. But others might be door-openers. And there are roasters glad when someone fills the gap somewhere in the chain.

    Lennart says that at This Side Up they see themselves as "The Good Middleman" because they take risk and pre-finance roasters. So I asked him further what wouldn't qualify as Direct Trade in his eyes.

    "I have a kind of split opinion. The obvious answer would be: if there is any kind of middleman there. But what qualifies as a middleman can get quite grey, because the work that we do and the work a roaster does is very similar in its execution. When a farmer and a roaster completely own the relationship and have all the communication, agree all the prices together, and they rely on a third party to finance them and to execute the trade in an equal partnership – that is a healthy situation. But I'm not sure whether it's direct trade. In my very strictest definition, even that would not be direct trade, because of the dependency that the financial middleman creates.

    So in an ideal world, direct trade would have a capital source to execute the trade that is regenerative, one where the power of the capital is shared between all the parties, between both ends of the value chain. And that hardly exists today. In my more easy-going definition I would say: if you do not own the relationship, if somebody else is doing the hard work of maintaining that relationship and you are basically just copy-pasting their work and saying 'this is direct trade' – that is the most common abuse that we see. That is also how a lot of people abuse the work of This Side Up. Because yes, we trade directly with them, and what we do together is something to be proud of. But then to use the term direct trade for it…"

    So if a roaster buys directly traded coffee from Lennart at six euros and then says "We as a roaster do Direct Trade," the term gets diluted. Yes, the coffee is Direct Trade according to Lennart if This Side Up buys from producers. But if a roaster then buys this directly traded coffee, it's a coffee that was previously directly traded. The roaster bought directly traded coffee, but hasn't done Direct Trade themselves.

    That's not a trifle and no semantic hairsplitting, but a completely different scenario. Here you're more of a freeloader. Not that that's good or bad. It's just different. Either someone buys for me or I do it all myself. From the perspective of the visionaries from the 2000s, a roaster buying coffee through This Side Up wouldn't be a Direct Trade roaster. But you know what so many say? That they do exactly that and are exactly that.

    "There are many people who show it as direct trade, which I disagree with, because basically they showcase the work that we do. Them being proud of buying that coffee because of all the work that is done in the partnership between This Side Up and the grower – that is fantastic, that makes everyone proud. But then to go one step ahead and call it direct trade means you are undercutting all the roasters who are doing that work. And that is what is so special about direct trade. That's also where we see the frustration of roasters who are doing this work and really involving themselves intimately in the reality of the producer, and then seeing that people are basically copy-pasting the good middleman's messages."

    And this happens because there's no strict definition and no measurable comparisons, let alone a ruleset everyone could appeal to.

    I know a few roasters who really do Direct Trade the way Lennart would define it. There's Quijote in Hamburg. There's Muyu from Locarno, importing coffee from Bolivia. There are brokers and several others who do it all themselves: select the coffee themselves, import themselves, finance themselves, year after year after year. These roasters are very close to the ideal communicated in the early 2000s. Other roasters then buy from Direct Trade roasters and adapt the model.

    I asked Lennart whether Direct Trade is an advantage for him and for working with This Side Up.

    "There could be, if you look at it from a monetary perspective, because some larger companies might use us to direct-wash their coffees. But in the end it doesn't benefit us at all, because we exist to facilitate direct trade. Our top ten roasters, if you look at it year on year, they switch all the time, because we help people move towards direct trade. That's why we exist, that's the objective of our company. People showing our work and calling it direct trade – it might sell. It's a good question. I don't know whether it actually sells, or whether it's the pride that sells. So they should stay away from the term if it is not true. But then again, we have not been very vocal about what is and isn't direct trade. We just showcase what we do. We're not in the term-defining business, as it were."

    Two things about this. First: I see myself there and I see us as Kaffeemacher. We avoid using Direct Trade. But we tell what we do. There's the occasional case where we pre-finance coffees early. We've also imported coffee ourselves, done all the export paperwork, even though we're not logistics people. But we usually work with importers doing direct trade and buy their directly traded coffee. That includes GEPA, Algrano, or also Quijote and others. Because we're freeloaders here, we at least avoid saying we do Direct Trade ourselves.

    Second: Lennart says he's not in the business of defining definitions. And yet we're discussing this. Again for context: when everyone uses a term that's so vague but at the same time so positively charged and represents a sales and positioning argument, then we have to define it rather than continue to soften it. Because if we keep softening, the term loses power.

    WHAT THE PRODUCER SAYS
    ---------------------------

    The discussion goes in circles if I only ask the processing side of the industry. So I asked a friend and coffee producer in Peru what he thinks about Direct Trade and what this approach brings him. Here's César Marín from Chacra de Dago in Peru.

    "Direct trade to me is not only about selling coffee without intermediaries, but about building a real relationship between producer and roasters. At the end of the day it's about speaking honestly about quality, price, climate, harvest, logistics and the many challenges that stay invisible behind the cup. In my case I travel often to Europe, because we believe the producer also needs to show a new face. We cannot only send the coffee and wait for feedback. We need to be present, explain our reality, understand the language of the roasters, have market knowledge and create trust and communication. In the end it is a relationship that we can build with time, transparency and mutual responsibility."

    Good, right? Honest exchange. Trust. Responsibility. Things that matter to him. I just wonder: isn't that simply a good approach to understanding and running trustworthy business? Being honest, trusting each other, and being responsible for each other are basically fundamental things. But apparently it's so far removed that we need a name for it.

    I asked César whether Direct Trade is better than other systems—the prevailing systems through which he would normally sell coffee.

    "I think it depends on an honest and serious relationship. A direct relationship can be beautiful if both sides are committed. But sometimes other partners also play an important role, especially when they help with financing and contracts and communication. For me it's not about saying direct trade is better than everything else. It's more about asking whether this business model creates more trust, more stability and more value for everyone involved. I think it's better, because it creates more of a human connection. When the relationship is strong, the roaster does not only buy big quantities, but they understand the process, they understand that the coffee they are buying is connected to the farm, to the family, to the territory and to decisions that started long before the coffee arrived at its destination. For producers, direct trade definitely helps us grow. It pushes us to improve quality, to understand the market, to communicate better and to show a more complete version of who we are."

    Through exchange and visits we learn the ideas and challenges of the other side. And that's really exciting. Honestly, I wish every roaster could earn the ability to work so closely with producers that everyone's wishes can be expressed at the same table and then discussed together as partners.

    So we're dealing with a term that's been swirling around for twenty years, perhaps even longer. This term can be more narrowly defined, as Lennart does, even speaking of directwashing when someone buys his directly traded coffee, roasts it, and then communicates it as Direct Trade. And we've heard an understanding that's much broader: César sees Direct Trade as a different form of trade, but especially of action—because Direct Trade for him is based on trust, exchange, and honesty.

    Maybe it would sometimes help if we spoke of direct action rather than direct trade. So actually getting into action and just doing it, rather than playing into the many ideas of coffee consumers that direct is always better. It's really about bringing transparency to coffee trade and leveling power and knowledge asymmetries. The question is just: how do we get there? It will be difficult if we don't have a shared language, grammar, and vocabulary.

    A DETOUR: WHY THERE'S NO DIRECT TRADE BIBLE
    ---------------------------------------------------

    I'm making a detour here. Warning, now comes a break. But trust me, I'll come back. Religions.

    Religions with sacred books have solved a central problem: canonization. At some point an authority said: that's in here, that's the standard now. And deviations are then heresy. That's verifiable, it's nameable, it's sanctionable. Whoever quotes a sacred book quotes the same document as everyone else.

    And Direct Trade has never done this so officially. There's no Direct Trade bible we can appeal to. There are intentions and visions. Some are more precise, others more confused to really meaningless. Some are more widely received because certain traders and roasters have more trust in the industry. There are meetings and conferences, for instance the Coretto in July 2025 in Hamburg, where roasters like Quijote, Coffee Collective, Flying Roasters, and also GEPA were present. In circles like these it's clear what Direct Trade means because their philosophy translated so strongly into action: pre-financing, long-term partnerships, regular visits through thick and thin. They don't even need to discuss it anymore, it just goes without saying.

    For most consumers, though, Direct Trade simply sounds good because it suggests closeness and therefore doesn't seem to need precise expression. And that's why there's this semantic black market. Much is allowed because it's not sanctioned. I can say just about anything and won't be held accountable. I can say I trade totally ethically and no one corrects me. I can say this coffee is fairer than Fairtrade and no one corrects me.

    IN CONVERSATION WITH PINGO FELSEN, QUIJOTE COFFEE
    --------------------------------------------

    So why is it so difficult to find a common rulebook? I asked one of the pioneers of direct trade in coffee in Germany: Andreas "Pingo" Felsen from Quijote Coffee.

    THE QUESTION OF QUALITY REMAINS
    ----------------------------------

    What remains is really the quality question. What Direct Trade can really do is break through the anonymity of traditional trade. There are voices saying quality can be higher in Direct Trade because you're in direct exchange with producers. Maybe. But very often there isn't actually this direct exchange, as we heard.

    Direct Trade must be compared with traditional anonymous trade. Only then do major cracks appear. There's no anonymity, there's direct exchange. And especially there's no substitution of coffee because suddenly a name hangs on the product.

    But I see another fundamental criticism of the claim that higher quality leads to higher prices. First, sales prices can be higher, yes—but income doesn't rise for that. Because high quality takes massively more work. And that's where the dog is buried.

    Who actually says what good quality is? For years there was a scoresheet everyone calibrated to. Everyone? No. Most producers don't even know how their coffee tastes. And that's why early Direct Traders were right to teach cupping skills so sellers and buyers could talk about the same impressions. What remains: this scoresheet, this familiar evaluation form that associates coffee quality with points, appears so neutral and yet is full of subjective judgments. If a point score at the end decides whether a coffee is purchased, then that's a weak argument that high quality leads to better living conditions. Because it takes more than that.

    Direct Trade is here to stay. Because sincerely-meant direct trade changes the world in small ways and creates new opportunities. But really only if we communicate precisely and don't appeal to the diffuse feelings of coffee consumers. Because that doesn't help anyone.

    DIRECT TRADE 2.0
    ----------------

    To conclude, let's flip the absence of a rulebook on its head. I mean: that's pretty great. If we don't have one, maybe one could come. Though Pingo thinks not much more will happen there. But what if there really could be a Direct Trade 2.0? There have already been many meetings about it. But who wants to bring themselves to say in a world of so many roasters: hey, this is now our new standard?

    A supporting tool might be the Transparent Coffee Guide, where roasters disclose their purchase prices. That's an important step to even be able to talk about prices. But Lennart thinks about Direct Trade quite a bit further. And maybe what he says next is Direct Trade 2.0.

    "This is evolving into a direct trade incubator. We have incubated a lot of roasting companies to become direct traders, but we have not really incubated producers to do the same. That is what we are working towards this year. We will start in Colombia. We have worked with a producer for the last eight years, and over time he has invited a lot of roasters to the field, they picked coffee together, they developed intimate relationships. Basically, when the coffee comes to Europe it is ninety percent sold, and he does all the selling himself. That's been going on for the last three, four years, and it kind of felt that our relationship was stagnating. So what do we do, what is the next step? That is what you see as the next step in our evolution: a kind of safe space for direct trade to develop, with the capital that we find together and in a community that we develop together.

    So it is not necessarily independence – I think direct trade 2.0 is interdependent, where we do not own it, where we have the guts to share the power that we build. We have the relationship, and we gave it to Juan Pablo in Colombia. The next step is also letting the middleman function go: having him set up an actual import entity in the Netherlands, for example. Because in the end, the middleman function we have is a placeholder. If you zoom out, fair enough, we have this position in the middle because we stole it. Colonialism is the basis of all coffee trade, and that power belongs in the hands of the farmers. So yeah, direct trade should be one where the power sits comfortably with the roaster and also the growers."

    So Lennart works at building relationships so strong that he can then take himself out again. He could keep everything in the company, but he spins out the relationships he's built himself. And I find that both brilliant and admirable.

    What do you think?

      Which machine should we test next?

      Espresso machine or grinder: Tell us what should be next on our test bench. We read every request.

      We only use your email to follow up on your request. You'll only receive the newsletter if you check the box and confirm. Privacy Policy