Home / Coffee knowledge / Eureka Black Diamond grinding discs in test: which one fits your espresso?
    Espressomühlen
    Eureka Black Diamond Mahlscheiben im Test: welche passt zu deinem Espresso?

    Eureka Black Diamond grinding discs in test: which one fits your espresso?

    It's burr time again. We kept getting the same question from the community: Which Eureka burr should I buy, which one fits my grinder and my espresso preferences? So we tested the various Black Diamond burrs, installed in the Eureka Single Dose Pro and, in the case of the All Purpose burr, in the Eureka Mignon Libra 65 All Purpose. For each burr, we had a particle distribution measured and drank our way through a decent number of espressos. The result is clearer than we thought.

    Black Diamond is two different things, and that's often confused

    Before we get to the measurements, we need to unpack a term. Because "Black Diamond" means two completely different things, and if you mix them up, you'll end up buying the wrong burr.

    One is the coating. The black burrs are mechanically identical to the standard ones, just coated and therefore more durable. The coating has no effect on the grind pattern or taste. We've measured this multiple times by now, including on the Magnifico and the Mignon XL. So if you just want to grind longer before the burrs wear out, you can confidently buy your existing geometry in black. Nothing more happens.

    The other is the geometry of the burr. And that changes the cup massively. Eureka offers multiple geometries under the Black Diamond label, and they taste so different that we wouldn't have guessed it was the same coffee in a blind tasting. That's exactly what this article is about.

    Three geometries compared

    We measured three burrs: the Italian Espresso Taste, the Espresso Specialty, and the All Purpose. All values in the table come from the same test setting (espresso basic setting, T4) and were determined in collaboration with ZHAW.

    Burr x50 (Median) Fines (<100 µm) Coarse Peak Width Character
    Italian Espresso Taste (Standard burr) 275.4 µm 29.7 % 218.5 µm body-forward, chocolatey, marzipan
    Espresso Specialty 292.9 µm 27.4 % 215.4 µm complex, sweet, less body
    All Purpose (in the Single Dose Pro) 239.5 µm 27.7 % 152.5 µm clear, bright acidity, elegant
    All Purpose (native in the Libra 65) 254.0 µm 27.3 % 142.0 µm clear, bright acidity, elegant

    Measurement values T4 (espresso basic setting), determined with the Retsch Camsizer X2 in cooperation with ZHAW. Reference coffee: Apas Espresso.

    Italian Espresso Taste: the standard burr, and it's already strong

    This is the burr you get when you order the Single Dose Pro normally. And we have to be clear: this is a great burr. The main peak is right on point at around 218 µm, plus a slightly higher fines content of just under 30 percent. That creates resistance in the puck and body in the cup.

    With the Apas, we pull body-forward, rather dark extractions, clearly into the chocolatey, very pronounced marzipan. Lots of body, dense texture. Interestingly: even though the burr isn't called "All Purpose," it also covers lighter roasts surprisingly broadly. For anyone who brings the reflex "I need to upgrade" from the home barista course, let's be clear: the base you already have is really delicious.

    Espresso Specialty: coarser, fewer fines, more complexity

    You might think the Specialty burr has a narrower main peak. It doesn't. We're talking about a difference of around 15 µm compared to the Italian, which isn't significant and both remain in the range of very good burrs. What does shift: the fines content drops by about three percent, and the x50 moves noticeably coarser.

    In the cup, that brings more complexity and lots of sweetness with fruity coffees. Great with the Apas, definitely with medium and darker roasts. With the lighter Chirinos, we were missing a bit of texture, the espresso ran a bit thin and lost presence. Not a bad espresso, but not the burr with which this light coffee shines.

    All Purpose: uncompromising clarity, but not for casual use

    Here everything flips. The main peak narrows to around 150 µm, the mountain becomes a point. That takes away the coffee's weight and gives it clarity, acidity, and complexity. Elegant rather than powerful. With the Apas, that brings out a completely different side, light marzipan, grape sweetness, notes that are actually untypical for our Apas.

    But: this burr demands appropriate brewing. With the light coffee, the result at a flat 9 bar was too acidic for us and no longer balanced. The All Purpose burr plays to its strengths only when you can back off the pressure, so with a lever machine, pressure profiles, or flow control. An example from the test: the light coffee came out at 28 seconds total time, but the first drops didn't appear until 14 seconds. A puck like that needs long saturation and then shoots through at the end. On a machine that just pushes flat through, that hurts the coffee. These are the most advanced burrs in the field, with which you can learn a lot.

    ★ Michel Aeschbacher, Swiss Vice Barista Champion

    "If we drink these side by side and didn't know it was the same coffee, I wouldn't assume it. Completely different."

    Which burr fits in which grinder?

    Important so nothing goes wrong here: the All Purpose burrs are standard in the Libra 65 All Purpose, and the grinder is precisely calibrated for them. All Purpose burrs grind very slowly, the Libra is designed for that.

    The other Black Diamond geometries only make sense in the Single Dose Pro. The dimensions and threading are the same, theoretically a lot fits together. In practice, however, the different grind speed in unmatched grinders quickly causes problems, up to and including clogs, and with scale grinders, the scale might not keep up. In short: we can't guarantee such conversions.

    Our Tip

    You don't have to buy new burrs at all. Your grinder's standard burr is already very good. A burr change is a conscious character switch for experimentation, not a mandatory upgrade. But if you feel like it, it's an exciting field that will keep you busy for weeks.

    Burr swap: recipes aren't transferable afterwards

    One point that's often underestimated in everyday use: if you change the geometry, your grind setting shifts significantly. On the Single Dose Pro, the grinding point (the point where the burrs scratch against each other) for the Apas is around setting 12 with the standard burr, around 9 with the All Purpose, and around 11 with the Espresso Specialty. For the light coffee, we needed about five more numbers finer.

    That means: if you have a dialed-in recipe and install new burrs, you can't just transfer that recipe. You have to dial in again. Plan for a couple of days until you've grooved back in with the new burr.

    Which burr for which espresso?

    In the end, it's a matter of taste, and all three are good burrs. As a rule of thumb:

    • Heavy, powerful, complex: stick with the Italian Espresso Taste or the Espresso Specialty. Both deliver body and sweetness, the Specialty a bit more complexity with fruity coffees.
    • Clarity, acidity, profiling: then the All Purpose burrs are highly interesting, provided you can work with pressure or flow on your machine.

    Black Diamond isn't a taste upgrade, it's two things: a coating for longer durability that doesn't change the grind pattern, and multiple burr geometries that significantly change the espresso. If you just want to grind longer, go with the black version of your existing burr. If you want to change the character, choose based on taste: Italian and Specialty for body and complexity, All Purpose for clarity and acidity, then please with a matching machine.

    And the most important sentence first: you don't need any of this. Your Eureka's standard burr is already very good. But if you feel like playing with your coffee, it's a field where you can really get a lot out of it over weeks.

    To figure out which Eureka grinder is right for you, best check our Eureka buying guide.

    What do you think?

      Which machine should we test next?

      Espresso machine or grinder: Tell us what should be next on our test bench. We read every request.

      We only use your email to follow up on your request. You'll only receive the newsletter if you check the box and confirm. Privacy Policy