Home / Coffee knowledge / Perfect coffee with the help of light – refractometers in coffee brewing
    Kaffeewissen
    Mit Licht zum perfekten Kaffee – Refraktometer in der Kaffeezubereitung

    Perfect coffee with the help of light – refractometers in coffee brewing

    Refractometers are scientific instruments that measure the refractive index of a liquid – in simple terms, how strongly light is bent in a medium. In the coffee world, the refractive index is directly linked to the concentration of dissolved substances in the coffee beverage, known as Total Dissolved Solids (TDS). The TDS value indicates what percentage of the beverage consists of dissolved coffee components – it is a measure of coffee strength. A stronger coffee has a higher TDS percentage, a weaker one correspondingly a lower percentage. By measuring TDS, baristas can objectively assess and reproducibly control the extraction in the brewing process.

    However, not every refractometer from laboratory supplies is suitable for coffee. A standard Brix meter measures sugar (1 °Bx = 1 g sucrose in 100 g solution). For coffee, you need a conversion factor: 10 °Bx corresponds to approximately 8.5% TDS (factor ~0.85). Inexpensive hand Brix meters also have only coarse scales (resolution often 0.2 °Bx ≈ 0.1% TDS) – too imprecise for the fine differences in filter coffee (~1.3% TDS). Specialized coffee refractometers are precisely calibrated for coffee solutions and deliver digital displays with two decimal places in seconds.

    TDS spectrum: Concentration by beverage type

    Percent dissolved coffee components (TDS) · typical reference values

    0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 12% Filter coffee 1.2 – 1.5 % French Press 1.2 – 1.7 % Café Crème 1.8 – 5 % Espresso 6 – 12 % Ristretto 10 %+

    Reference values · may vary depending on recipe and roast

    TDS says nothing about quality – in brief

    The TDS value alone does not provide information about the actual sensory quality of an extraction. Tasting is essential for assessing quality. Nevertheless, a refractometer helps in many ways:

    • The strength or concentration of dissolved coffee particles can be measured.
    • TDS is a prerequisite for calculating extraction. This gives us an indication of whether a coffee is under- or over-extracted.
    • The values signal changes in the material (e.g., dulling grinding burrs), water, pressure, coffee aging, or channeling.
    • Different espresso machine types, basket sizes, tamping techniques, and fill amounts can be compared with their extraction results.
    • Different coffees (origin, altitude, variety) can be discovered anew when they show very different extraction values under constant parameters.
    Refractometer measuring

    VST Refractometer in action

    Overview of common coffee refractometers

    In specialty coffee, some digital refractometers have become established, which vary in precision, features, and price. Here's an overview of the three best-known models:

    Model Accuracy Price Special feature
    VST LAB Coffee III ±0.02 % (Filter)
    ±0.05 % (Espresso)
    ~1,000 € Gold standard, sapphire optics, software included
    Atago PAL-COFFEE ±0.15 % ~450 € Robust, water-resistant, up to 100 °C
    DiFluid R2 Extract ±0.02 % ~250 € Bluetooth app, USB rechargeable, IP67

    VST LAB Coffee III

    The Lab Coffee Refractometer from Voice Systems Technology (VST) is considered the gold standard in the industry. We have three models – and they've been serving for over ten years.

    The VST refractometer measures from 0.00 % to approximately 20 % TDS with an accuracy of ±0.02 % (typical). Automatic temperature compensation in the range 15–40 °C, sapphire optics, and a 1024-pixel sensor array ensure reliable measurements. VST supplies the CoffeeTools software directly – it has been used for years at world championships (Brewers Cup, Barista Championship) as the official tool. The price is in the four-digit range.

    Atago PAL-COFFEE

    The PAL-COFFEE from Japanese manufacturer Atago is a handy pocket refractometer. We have been using a PAL-Coffee refractometer since 2018 – in brewing courses and at championships.

    Measurement time ~3 seconds, automatic temperature compensation up to 100 °C, accuracy ±0.15 % TDS. Sufficient for espresso, slightly coarse for filter coffee. The robust, water-resistant design makes it ideal for the hectic café environment.

    DiFluid refractometer

    DiFluid R2 Extract

    The DiFluid R2 Extract from China has caused a stir since 2022 as an affordable alternative. Despite the low price, it offers an accuracy of ±0.02 % TDS, is USB rechargeable, and IP67 water-resistant. So even if an espresso spills on it, it's fine.

    Particularly practical: The R2 connects via Bluetooth to the DiFluid Café app, which saves measurements, creates statistics, and updates the device. An ideal tool for ambitious home baristas or as a second refractometer to take along.

    Coffee refractometer
    Simple analog refractometers are unsuitable for coffee

    They are often only designed for high Brix values, too inaccurate in the low TDS range, and require manual reading. Anyone who wants to work seriously with coffee measurement will choose the coffee-specific devices mentioned above.

    Operating principle and correct use

    The refractometer sends a light beam through the sample onto a prism and measures the angle at which the light exits. The more concentrated the solution, the stronger the light bends. Above a certain angle of incidence, total internal reflection occurs – this critical angle depends directly on the refractive index of the liquid. From the critical angle, the device calculates the TDS value.

    Since coffee consists of hundreds of chemical compounds, the relationship between refractive index and TDS is not simply linear. VST analyzed thousands of samples to develop their algorithms – refractometrically and by drying. Modern coffee refractometers contain these empirical curve formulas as a chip, so that reliable percentages are obtained from light refraction.

    Equally important is temperature compensation. Heat changes the density of a liquid and thus the refractive index. All high-quality devices have automatic temperature compensation (ATC), but this still applies: For maximum accuracy, allow the sample to cool to room temperature, especially for espresso.

    Coffee solutions – especially espresso – always contain the finest insoluble particles and emulsified oils, which can distort the refractive index. For precise measurements, use filter paper or syringe filters (e.g., 0.5 µm pore size). Filtered espresso samples typically show a slightly lower, but more reproducible, TDS value.

    Step by step: How to measure with the refractometer

    1
    Calibrate: With distilled water, check that the refractometer reads 0.00 % (zero adjustment). This excludes measurement drift and residue on the prism.
    2
    Stir sample and withdraw: Draw the sample up and push it out several times with the pipette or syringe so that crema and coffee mix well. Only a well-homogenized sample provides a representative value.
    3
    Filter (if necessary): For espresso, French press, or Moka pot, filter the sample through a syringe filter or V60 filter to clarify it. Removes suspended solids that can distort the measurement. Optional in everyday use – recommended for measurement series.
    4
    Allow to cool: Bring sample to approximately 20 °C. As it cools, the TDS value increases slightly because density increases. Wait briefly or stir to room temperature.
    5
    Measure: Place one or two drops on the prism, close the lid, start the measurement. Modern devices deliver the result in seconds and display TDS directly as a percentage.
    6
    Clean: Clean the prism immediately with water and a lint-free cloth. Dried coffee residue impairs the next measurement.

    Coffee strength (TDS) and extraction rate (EY) explained

    Once the TDS value has been determined, the question arises: Is that good or bad? This is where extraction rate (Extraction Yield, EY) comes in. It indicates how much percent of the original coffee powder has dissolved into the solution. If you brew 20 g of coffee and end up with 4 g of it dissolved in the cup, you've extracted 20 %. Under-extraction results in sour, thin-tasting coffee, over-extraction leads to bitterness. Balance is traditionally found at 18–22 % extraction.

    Calculate extraction rate

    Formula for determining Extraction Yield (EY)

    EYExtraction (%)
    =
    TDS × Beverage% × Grams

    Coffee amountGrams
    Example from the video
    6.18 % × 52 g
    TDS × Weight in cup

    18 g
    Coffee amount (dose)
    =
    17.8 %Extraction

    17.8 % is slightly below the ideal range (18–22 %) – a bit more body would have been possible.

    In addition to extraction, strength (TDS) itself influences the sensory experience. An espresso with 10 % TDS and 20 % extraction tastes fundamentally different from a filter coffee with 1.3 % TDS at 20 % extraction – despite identical extraction rates. The first is ten times more concentrated. For different brewing methods, typical TDS ranges have therefore become established: filter coffee approximately 1.2–1.5 %, espresso approximately 8–12 %, Moka pot approximately 3–5 %, French Press approximately 1.2–1.7 %, Cold Brew typically 1.4–1.6 %, Cupping approximately 1.2–1.4 %.

    Brewing Control Chart – Filter coffee

    SCA standard · Extraction vs. strength (TDS)

    12% 14% 16% 18% 20% 22% 24% 26% 28% Extraction (Extraction Yield) 1.0% 1.15% 1.3% 1.45% 1.6% Strength (TDS) UNDER-EXTRACTION sour · thin · unbalanced OVER-EXTRACTION bitter · astringent · dry IDEAL Golden Cup Standard Example 1.35% · 20.3% EY

    SCA Golden Cup Standard · for filter coffee · kaffeemacher.de

    Apps and software as helpers

    No barista today has to do calculations with a pocket calculator and brewing diagrams anymore. There are apps designed for exactly that and often work seamlessly with the refractometers:

    • VST CoffeeTools: The software developed by VST (PC/Mac) accepts TDS, coffee amount, and beverage weight and calculates extraction and graphical evaluations. Included with the purchase of the VST refractometer.
    • MoJo To Go: A mobile app from VST – famous because it ran on the iPod Touch from 2010 and first brought baristas an "extraction toy" in their pocket. I bought an iPhone just for this app back then. Today part of the CoffeeTools family.
    • DiFluid Café App: Receives live TDS via Bluetooth, calculates the extraction rate after entering dose and output, and displays your brew as a point in the SCA brewing diagram. Values can also be integrated into Bean Conqueror.
    • SmartRef Coffee Meister: App from Anton Paar for their SmartRef laboratory refractometer. Calculates TDS and extraction – more geared toward roasters and labs.
    EXERCISE FOR SENSORY TRAINING
    Lock in TDS, vary extraction

    Strength remains constant at 1.35 % · Extraction varies from 14 % to 28 %

    1.35% TDS 14% 16% 18% 20% 22% 24% 26% 28% UNDER-EXTRACTION IDEAL OVER-EXTRACTION 14% 16% 18% 20% 22% 24% 26% 28% Extraction (Extraction Yield)
    14–16 % EY
    sour · thin
    underdeveloped
    18–22 % EY
    balanced · sweet
    Golden Cup Standard
    24–28 % EY
    bitter · astringent
    dry finish

    This is my absolute favorite recommendation as an exercise to improve your own sensory perception: lock in TDS at 1.35 % and then work through all extraction values from 14 to 28 %. The strength stays the same, but you'll notice very clearly how under-extraction and over-extraction feel at identical intensity. No textbook conveys this as clearly as this direct comparison.

    Critical reflection: Accuracy, sources of error, and benefits

    For all the enthusiasm about precise measurements: A refractometer is a tool, not a taste oracle.

    • Absolute accuracy vs. practice: Manufacturers advertise ±0.02 % TDS. In practice, the actual deviation can be higher, depending on calibration and careful handling. The Atago has ±0.15 % – a true TDS of 1.30 % could thus be displayed as 1.15 % or 1.45 %. For comparative measurements (recipe A vs. B), all devices are sufficiently accurate. But: No palate in the world can taste the difference between 1.37 % and 1.40 % TDS.
    • Sources of error: Residue from the last coffee on the prism, sample not properly mixed, not filtered, measured too hot – all of this distorts the value. Always stir well, pipette cleanly, zero the device. Repeat measurements should differ by no more than ±0.03 %, otherwise there's a user error.
    • Oils in espresso: Coffee oils are hydrophobic and can slightly affect the refractive index as an emulsion. Therefore: Always proceed the same way – either always filter or never filter. In competitions and labs, filtering is standard.
    • TDS is not taste: The refractometer measures quantity, not quality. Two coffees can have identical TDS and EY and taste completely different. Numbers don't lie, but they don't tell the whole story. A high extraction value of 24 % doesn't necessarily indicate over-extraction – if the coffee still tastes good, it's not.
    • Frowning in the community: There were remarks like "If you don't know TDS and EY, you're not a competent barista." This understandably caused displeasure. Today, the discussion is more objective. The refractometer demystifies some aspects of brewing but doesn't take away creativity or sensory fine-tuning.

    If the coffee tastes watery and the refractometer confirms a TDS of 1.0 % (instead of 1.3 %), you know objectively: too thin – next time increase dose or grind finer. This way you learn to link cause and effect faster.

    Scientific context and new insights

    Full immersion, fixed extraction

    In 2021, a study (Liang et al., Scientific Reports) showed that in immersion brews, the extraction rate is fixed within a narrow range – a thermodynamic equilibrium. During cuppings between 80 °C and 99 °C, equilibrium extraction was always around ~20 %, regardless of water volume. More water dilutes the coffee (TDS drops) but doesn't significantly increase percentage extraction.

    TDS vs. taste – Cold brew vs. hot brew

    In 2022, Batali et al. examined the sensory difference between cold brew and hot-brewed coffee at identical TDS (~2 %). Result: Hot-brewed coffee tasted more bitter and sour, cold-brewed tasted sweeter and more floral. So brewing temperature influences which substances are extracted – even when the total amount is the same.

    Extraction Yield Strength

    Grinding, fines, and extraction dynamics

    A 2024 paper (Smrke et al., Scientific Reports) examined the influence of fines on espresso extraction. More fines → lower permeability, slower flow, higher extraction yield. But: Aroma compounds don't increase linearly with extraction. At some point, volatile aromas dissipate during the longer pull. An espresso with 25 % extraction could have less aroma in the cup than one with 22 %. Learning: A uniform grind with moderate fines content favors both flow and taste balance.

    Conclusion on the refractometer

    Refractometers have evolved from a laboratory instrument to a secret weapon of modern coffee brewing. In my daily brewing practice, the refractometer rarely comes out – but for test series, championship preparations, and setting up recipes in our cafés, it's a central tool.

    Especially when preparing for national Brewers Cup championships – but also at the World Brewers Cup in Rimini 2024 – the refractometer has helped me understand filter coffee and espresso brewing much better. It has also helped improve my own sensory perception. Twelve years after buying my first refractometer, I still love playing with the device: brew coffee, estimate TDS, measure – and even if I'm wrong, I learn something.

    Models like the VST, Atago, or DiFluid offer the right tool for different needs. Combined with apps, dialing in recipes becomes a data-driven pleasure. Still, this applies: The numbers serve taste, not the other way around. A refractometer tells you what happened – whether the result is good, your tongue and nose still decide.

    Ultimately, refractometers are a valuable tool to ensure consistency and support learning processes. When you bring both together – sensory expertise and measurement data – you can almost alchemically tinker with coffee perfection. May your coffee be delicious and your TDS on point. ☕️

    What do you think?

      Which machine should we test next?

      Espresso machine or grinder: Tell us what should be next on our test bench. We read every request.

      We only use your email to follow up on your request. You'll only receive the newsletter if you check the box and confirm. Privacy Policy